AfriForum v Mail and Guardian
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PSCA 000585
Author: Jozias Mahube-Reinecke
Headline: Charge AfriForum, Solidariteit over white ‘genocide’ hoax
Publication Date: 17 April 2026
Date lodged: 20 April 2026
Link to story: https://mg.co.za/thought-leader/opinion/2026-04-17-charge-afriforum-solidariteit-over-white-genocide-hoax/
Particulars
- This complaint was submitted by Louis Boshoff, AfriForum’s campaigns officer, on behalf of the organisation.
The article
- Jozias Mahube-Reinecke, the author, is presented as a political activist and a law graduate from the University of Pretoria.
- The article is about AfriForum’s engagement with the USA about alleged discrimination against white people in South Africa, with special reference to farm murders. The term “white genocide” is used in this regard.
- The author argues quite extensively that AfriForum should be charged with high treason, inter alia because:
a. it engaged with a foreign power, which led to economic pressure on the state;
b. it showed no allegiance to their own state; and
c. there was hostile intent on its part.
The complaint
- AfriForum complains about the following statement: “AfriForum and their allied organisations frame their position through claims of targeted violence against white farmers, which they present in international advocacy as a form of ‘white genocide’…”
- Boshoff submits that this statement is neither truthful nor accurate and that is therefore in breach of Section 1.1 of the Press Code.
- The campaigns officer adds that it also cannot be fair comment, as it has not taken fair account of all material facts (with reference to Section 7.2 of the Code).
Relief sought
- AfriForum asks for a Tier 3 sanction, since it regards this as a repeat offence. Boshoff refers to two instances where the Mail & Guardian had to apologise for the same matter.
Reply to the complaint
- Editor-in-Chief Japhet Ncube emphasises that the article was not “straight news reportage”, as it was an opinion piece.
- He denies that the text states that AfriForum “expressly said, in Washington or elsewhere, that there is a white genocide in South Africa. Nor does it purport to reproduce a verbatim quotation. The sentence is framed in the language of analysis: it refers to how AfriForum and its allies ‘frame their position’ and how those claims are ‘present[ed] in international advocacy as a form of’ white-genocide politics.”
- He adds that the sentence also expressly limits its own function by stating that the claim operates “as a basis for mobilisation rather than as a question for determination within this legal analysis”.
- Ncube notes that, because of AfriForum’s actions, the White House later published material headlined “POTUS on South Africa: ‘It’s a genocide’.” Reuters then reported that President Donald Trump confronted President Cyril Ramaphosa on 21 May 2025 with claims of white genocide and land seizures. “That sequence is relevant because it shows how the Washington campaign was publicly taken up and radicalised by the administration AfriForum had lobbied,” he argues.
- The editor-in-chief says that this point is reinforced by AfriForum’s own later rhetoric. In its 28 May 2025 statement, AfriForum said it had focused on the seriousness of farm murders rather than “semantic debates” about the term genocide, but that it had now become necessary to test the government’s conduct against the meaning of genocide. In the same statement, Kallie Kriel referred to a “very clear genocidal intent”.
- Besides, he continuous, the article was not written to adjudicate whether white genocide exists, nor to prove that AfriForum uttered a slogan. “It used AfriForum’s trip, lobbying and the consequences that followed as the factual basis for an argument about the common law of treason and whether South African law may require conceptual development to address forms of externalised pressure exerted through foreign power rather than direct force.”
Rejoinder
- Boshoff reiterates that the disputed sentence did not take fair account of all material facts, as AfriForum has never claimed that there is a white genocide in South Africa.
- Boshoff also argues that, by seeing the term “white genocide” placed in quotation marks, many readers would have concluded that it is the author’s direct factual attribution of quoted words to AfriForum, whether he intended it or not. “At the very least, the author is falsely claiming that AfriForum indirectly created the impression that there is a white genocide in South Africa.”
- To the newspaper’s argument that it was entitled to analyse AfriForum’s Washington advocacy as contributing to an international narrative severe enough to trigger refugee-style executive action, Boshoff replies the author was entitled to do that, but he was “not entitled” to analyse the matter as presenting farm murders to be a form white genocide”.
- Boshoff says there rests “no particular obligation” on AfriForum to change the Trump administration’s views on what consists of a genocide and what not. “Any lack of an attempt to do such, cannot be construed as the actual presentation of a ‘white genocide’ narrative.”
- He emphasises that a public narrative about white persecution in South Africa, which represents AfriForum’s stance, is not the same as that of a white genocide.
Analysis
The nature of the text
- Firstly, the article is published under the word “Opinion”. This is of vital importance, as it means that Section 1.1 of the Press Code, which demands that reportage be true, accurate and fair, is not applicable to this text – that section is particularly aimed at the reporting of news.
- Instead, Section 7.2 is relevant in this case.
The sentence in dispute
- It reads, “AfriForum and their allied organisations frame their position through claims of targeted violence against white farmers, which they present in international advocacy as a form of ‘white genocide’…”
- Section 7.2 of the Press Code 7.2 reads, “Comment or criticism is protected even if it is extreme, unjust, unbalanced, exaggerated and prejudiced, as long as it is without malice, is on a matter of public interest, has taken fair account of all material facts that are either true or reasonably true, and is presented in a manner that it appears clearly to be comment.”
- The operative words, as Boshoff correctly points out, are: “…has taken fair account of all material facts…” AfriForum’s argument is that it has never claimed that a white genocide is taking place in South Africa.
- It is true that AfriForum has several times denied that there is a white genocide taking place in South Africa. However, times change and so do people. In an interview with Kallie Kriel by eNCA, the journalist specially and explicitly asks him whether he accepts or rejects Trump’s statement that a white genocide is taking place in this country. He did reply, “no, we disagree…”. However, he did not see his way open to outright reject that statement. Instead, he argued that South Africans should be thankful that Trump recognises the problems in the country.
- This creates doubt. How serious is AfriForum in its denial of a white genocide in this country? I believe that question was in the author’s mind.
- I note that this interview took place prior to the publication of the disputed article – which means that Mahube-Reinecke most probably was aware of it. I therefore do not blame him if he thought that AfriForum’s position on white genocide was ambivalent.
- More importantly, though: I also consider that, after AfriForum’s visit to America, the White House called it a “white genocide” and that Trump even phoned Ramaphosa about it, believing that there was such a genocide – and acting upon it. I am quite sure that this has played a part in the author’s assessment of the matter.
- Considering that the article does not explicitly say that AfriForum calls farm murders a genocide but instead states that the organisation “presents” it as a white genocide, the statement in dispute is reasonable as it accurately reflects the outcome of AfriForum’s visit to Trump.
- The following statement by Boshoff calls for a response: “At the very least, the author is falsely claiming that AfriForum indirectly created the impression that there is a white genocide in South Africa.” That is indeed not a false claim – as Trump’s reaction proves.
- Boshoff’s statement that there rests no obligation on AfriForum to change the Trump administration’s views on a white genocide in South Africa is also quite troubling. If AfriForum did leave a wrong impression with Trump, as it says, one would expect it to correct that misunderstanding – especially because of the repercussions that followed. Why not correct the matter?
- Boshoff’s statement that the columnist was “not entitled” to analyse the matter as presenting farm murders to be a form white genocide is also problematical. I accept that he interprets the matter differently – but surely, the journalist was “entitled” to his opinion?
- In conclusion, then: If AfriForum did not present the situation in South Africa as a white genocide, as the article says, then why did Trump come to that conclusion after its visit?
Apologies published
- Boshoff says that the article breaches the Press Code on the same matter for which it had previously apologised and argues that this represents a repeat offence which should evoke a severe sanction.
- This argument is, with respect, not germane. The two apologies to which he refers, were for news stories in which it was stated as a fact that AfriForum’s view was that farm murders in the country constituted a white genocide.[1] In this case, as I have pointed out under Point 25, this text is an opinion piece, which is regulated not by Section 1.1 of the Code, but by Section 7.2.
- Those apologies are therefore not relevant to this complaint.
Finding
The complaint is dismissed.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
12 May 2026
[1] Those apologies appear in stories headlined, “AfriForum decries SA farm murders down under” (published on 15 October 2018) and “Mbalula dares US to bring on sanctions against ANC leaders” (published on 5 September 2025).
