Appeal Hearing Decision: News24 vs Phillip Rakgwale
BEFORE THE APPEALS PANEL OF THE PRESS COUNCIL OF SOUTH AFRICA
In the matter between
News24 Appellant
and
Phillip Rakgwale Respondent
Matter no: 00656/05/2026
___________________________________________________________________
DECISION
__________________________________________________________________
- This is an appeal by News24 (appellant) and a cross-appeal by Mr Phillip Rakgwale (respondent) against a Ruling by the Acting Press Ombud dated 25 June 2026. The Ruling followed a complaint that had been lodged by the respondent in respect of an article published by the appellant on 15 April 2026 with the heading: “Ekurhuleni millions: Questionable operations of shadowy company involved in toilet scandal.” A company had been awarded a tender by the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality to provide toilets. Irregularities were alleged, including in particular against the respondent. The Acting Ombud dismissed some of the complaints while upholding others; he then imposed a sanction. The appellant was granted leave to appeal, while the respondent was also granted leave to cross-appeal.
- This is the context of the dispute: There was a preliminary report by the metro’s Chief Auditor, the late Mpho Mafole, which was clearly marked “DRAFT” and was attached to the respondent’s complaint as “Annexure C4”, and which may not be confused with a subsequent report by Mafole to be referred to later. Mafole said that he did not scope in losing bidders, while the Audit Committee dealt with the winning bidders. The article reported that Mafole’s report was altered and sanitized by the respondent’s report, an allegation we return to later.
- In his Ruling, the Acting Ombud held that:
3.1 The appellant acted in breach of Section 1.2 of the Press Code in that the appellant did not publish that the report on which it based its reportage was, by the appellant’s own admission, a draft.
3.2 The appellant acted in breach of Sections 1.1 and 3.3 in that the article singled out the respondent as the only one responsible for the altering and sanitizing of Mafole’s report, while the decision was not taken by him alone.
A sanction was then imposed.
- Regarding the finding in 3.1, the appellant has conceded its correctness; the only thing remaining is the determination of its sanction.
- The finding in 3.2 above has two legs:
5.1 It accepts that there was some “altering and sanitizing” of Mafole’s report; this finding is disputed and cross-appealed by the respondent.
5.2 The second leg of the finding is about whether the alleged altering and sanitizing of Mafole’s report was done by the respondent alone or by the Committee he chaired. The Acting Ombud ruled that the appellant wrongly accused the respondent of taking the said decision alone, and imposed a sanction. The appellant appeals this ruling on the ground that there was no complaint by the respondent that he was being accused of altering and sanitizing Mafole’s report alone; therefore, it argues, the Acting Ombud’s finding that the appellant had wrongly accused the respondent of having done so alone was an overreach.
We deal with the above arguments separately.
- Regarding 5.1: The Acting Ombud’s finding that Mafole’s report was altered and sanitized, is incorrect and must be set aside. There was no sanitization of Mafole’s report. It is important to note that Mafole eventually (after the draft report referred to earlier) produced a report in the form of a memorandum dated 27 June 2025 which he submitted to the respondent on the same day. The email trail shows that Mafole first shared his report with his relevant colleagues for possible inputs or comments before finally emailing it to the respondent at 15:42 the same day. After the respondent received this report, he says it was considered by the Audit Committee, which he chaired. The Committee adopted Mafole’s report word for word, without any change, on the same 27th, which the respondent then signed and submitted to the Chief Financial Officer, Mr Lerutla, by email of 28 June 2025. Initially, we were not shown Mafole’s above report of 27 June 2025 by the respondent, but he circulated a copy thereof amongst us during the hearing, together with the email trail referred to above. As said already, the report is identical to the one signed by the respondent and emailed to Mr Lerutla on 28 June 2025. The Acting Ombud’s finding that Mafole’s report was sanitized, cannot therefore stand.
- Regarding 5.2: As already mentioned, the appellant argues that the Acting Ombud overreached in adjudicating a complaint that, according to the appellant, was never filed. In the process though, the appellant concedes that the respondent did not act alone in the alleged altering and sanitazing of Mafole’s report. It is therefore not necessary to deal with the point that the respondent did not act alone. It is obvious he did not act alone. The only issue in dispute is therefore whether or not there was indeed such a complaint filed by the respondent, namely, that he was wrongly accused of having acted alone.
- To bolster its argument that the Acting Ombud adjudicated a complaint that was never lodged, the appellant says that the Acting Ombud called for some background information from which a complaint (that was never made) was supported. This argument is wrong. The background document did not found a complaint that was never raised by the respondent in his complaint; the complaint was raised in there from the beginning, though perhaps not well articulated – something which is understandable as the respondent is not a lawyer. The Appeals Panel has repeatedly recognized that non-lawyer complainants may not be as accurate as lawyers in formulating their complaints; otherwise many complaints would be rejected. Throughout his complaint, the respondent was at pains to show that he did not act alone, precisely to counter such an accusation by the appellant. This was therefore part of his complaint. The appellant’s argument that it did not convey that the respondent acted alone or carried individual culpability is also belied by the fact that it persisted throughout that “the buck stopped” with the respondent. The message that the respondent carried individual culpability was patent. It was also taken to the professional bodies to which he belonged, all of which exonerated him. Not once did the appellant seek to clarify that it did not attach personal culpability to the respondent alone; instead, as already mentioned, it persisted that the buck stopped with the respondent.
Orders
- The following Order is therefore made Regarding Findings:
9.1 The Acting Press Ombud’s finding that the report signed by Mr Phillip Rakgwale was altered and sanitized, is hereby set aside; and replaced by the following: News 24 acted in breach of Section 3.3 of the Code in saying that the respondent altered and sanitized Mafole’s report.
9.2 By stating that Mr Phillip Rakgwale acted alone in producing the final report, News24 acted in breach of Section 1.1 of the Code.
- The following Order is made regarding Sanctions:
10.1.a. Paragraph 96 of the Acting Ombud’s Ruling is set aside and replaced by the following: News24 is directed to apologize to Mr Phillip Rakgwale for saying he altered and sanitized Molefe’s report singling him out, and thus causing him some unnecessary harm; and
10.1. b. News24 is reprimanded for not referring to the document on which it based its article as a draft report.
10.2 Paragraph 97 of the Ruling by the Acting Ombud is hereby confirmed and must be implemented.
Dated this 18th day of November 2026
Judge B M Ngoepe, Chair, Appeals Panel
Ms J Sandison, Member, Press Representative
Ms H Veljoen, Member, Public Representative
