News24 vs City Power
BEFORE THE APPEALS PANEL OF THE PRESS COUNCIL OF SOUTH AFRICA
In the matter between
News24 Applicant
and
City Power Respondent
Matter no: 00747/08/2026
________________________________________________________________
DECISION ON AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
___________________________________________________________________
- This is an application by News24 (applicant) for leave to appeal a Ruling by the Acting Press Ombud, dated 14 September 2026. It was a ruling on a complaint that was lodged by City Power (respondent) in respect of an article published by the applicant on 24 May 2026 under the headline “City Power spin doctor Mangena implicated in tender interference, dirty tricks campaign”. The headline speaks for itself as to what the essence of the article was about. Mr Mangena was the respondent’s spokesperson. The article said he was implicated in some tender interference; that he introduced his friend, another Mangena, to an important official of the respondent, one Marvin Baepi; that Mangena the spokesperson and his colleagues were behind a coordinated campaign to falsely discredit applicant’s investigative journalist, Khaya Koko, and that another person, a pastor, also falsely implicated the journalist in an affidavit in an alleged extortion racket.
- The respondent formulated a number of complaints around the above statements, which were disputed by the applicant in various ways; the respondent also replicated. It would be appropriate to state that the submissions on behalf of each party were presented in the form of unpaginated and unparagraphed mass of papers difficult to read and follow. This resulted in the papers not being arranged in the correct order. It therefore took me a lot of effort and time to make chronological sense of the mass of those papers.
- The Acting Ombud dismissed a lot of complaints, except for the following findings:
“The following statements of fact in the article should have been presented as allegations:
- That Mangena was behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting Koko;
- That CP officials including in Mangena’s department, were responsible for sending the Baepi story to three national publications; and
- That CP’s seniormost executives were involve in dangerous efforts to discredit one another.”
- He found the above to have been in breach of Clauses 1.3 and 3.3 of the Press Code, and imposed a sanction.
- The applicant now seeks leave to appeal the Acting Ombud’s Ruling, which application is opposed by the respondent. Leave to appeal will only be granted if the applicant would have reasonable prospects of success before the Appeals Panel. I must now determine that. In doing so, I am only looking at the complaint that was upheld, submissions by the two parties including submissions for and against the application. Naturally, I have read the Acting Ombud’s analysis and reasons with regard to the findings in question.
- The applicant, in its application for leave to appeal, does acknowledge that the Acting Ombud dealt in detail with the matter but raises some points which amount to some hair-splitting exercise and which are not germane to the main issue, namely, that the offensive statements were wrongly expressed as statements of fact instead of mere allegations. For example, the applicant says that the “central thrust of (its) appeal is that the acting press ombud appears not to have engaged with a critical set of questions (it) sent to Mr Mangena … 11 days before the publication….” Which, it says, Mr Mangena ignored. The applicant went on: “News24 will argue that Mr Mangena’s lack of engagement with the allegations and direct questions was negligent and led to the elements of (its) reporting he is now complaining of, or alternatively, was part of a stratagem ….” If indeed what is said above is the central thrust of the appeal, it shows how meritless the intended appeal is. None of the above provides justification for stating as a fact what was a mere allegation. Let me go further. Harping on the absence of a comment, it is argued that the “second request (by the journalist) for comment, sent to Mr Mangena and Ms Motsepe on 12 May 2026, is absent, leading News24 to believe the document and its contents were not considered.” This is a huge assumption, belied by the thorough manner in which the Acting Ombud analyzed the facts. Heavy weather is then made of the request or requests. This is an example of what I described earlier as a hair-splitting exercise to find fault with the Ruling. In any case, failure to respond did not justify reporting an allegation as a fact. Moreover, in opposing the application, the respondent points out that the so-called “central thrust” does not properly reflect the correspondence between the parties. Note the following point by the respondent: “The issue was not whether News24 was entitled to investigate these circumstances or form a view about them. The issue was whether its conclusions had reached the level at which they could properly be presented to readers as established facts rather than allegations, inferences or interpretations” This was the crux of the matter and the problem with the applicant’s reportage.
- In the circumstances, the application for leave to appeal has no prospects of success and it is dismissed.
Dated this 18th day of November 2026.
Judge B M Ngoepe, Chair, Appeals Panel
