Bojane Segooa v Financial Mail
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PCSA 000734
Headline: A good week for Bojane Segooa – The former Daybreak board chair stepped smoothly into a new job with student funding body NSFAS
Publication Date: 23 July 2026
Date lodged: 27 July 2026
Link to text: https://fm.co.za/news-and-fox/2026-07-23-a-good-week-for-bojane-segooa/
Particulars
- This finding is based on correspondence by Bojane Segooa and that of Rob Rose, editor-in-chief for and on behalf of the Financial Mail Group (Proprietary) Limited.
The article
- The full text of the article in dispute reads as follows:
a. “Overseeing the financial train wreck of Daybreak Foods – the poultry producer majority-owned by the Public Investment Corporation that spiralled into one of the country’s biggest state-linked investment collapses – turned out to be no obstacle to Bojane Segooa getting a new job and a soft landing;
b. “The former Daybreak board chair quit amid the scandal and received a R625,000 payout. She has been appointed to the audit committee of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme, but with the scheme’s recent history, she might wish she were back on the farm.”
3. The caption to a picture of her reads, “FLYING THE COOP: Bojane Segooa, chair of Daybreak’s five-person board of directors, resigned with immediate effect, leaving fellow board members dumbstruck.”
The complaint
The caption
- Segooa complains that the impression is created that she resigned abruptly, while the text omits material facts that are relevant to that inference. She says this includes documented security threats, intimidation and incidents affecting members of the Board. “These omitted facts materially alter the context within which readers understand [her] resignation.”
- She adds that the use of the word “dumbstruck” creates a misleading impression.
- She presents the following as supporting evidence:
a. Her media statement dated 22 September 2025, in which she states that she resigned from Daybreak Foods because of serious personal safety threats, not because of the company’s instability or any wrongdoing on her part;
b. Email correspondence, addressing a toxic and potentially lethal situation regarding Board members, as well as investigations by the Hawks into alleged criminal activity.
‘Overseeing the financial train wreck of Daybreak Foods — the poultry producer majority-owned by the Public Investment Corporation that spiralled into one of the country’s biggest state-linked investment collapses…’
- Segooa complains that the words “overseeing the financial train wreck of Daybreak Foods” inaccurately attributes the problem to her tenure as interim chairperson. Instead, Daybreak Foods was already in severe financial distress before her appointment, largely due to the industry-wide impact of the 2023 Avian Influenza outbreak.
- “It also omits that I served as interim chairperson for less than 3 months and that, during this period, the Board secured a successful TERS application to support employee salaries and resolved to place the company into Business Rescue to maximise the prospects of rehabilitation,” she says.
- She supplies me, inter alia, with correspondence, showing:
a. that she was notified on 4 June 2024 by the PIC Investment Corporation, which approved her appointment as chairperson of the Audit Committee of Daybreak Farms; and
b. how dangerous and volatile the situation was.
‘The former Daybreak board chair quit amid the scandal and received a R625,000 payout.’
- Segooa complains that this statement frames the R625 000 payment as an improper payout linked to her departure from Daybreak Foods. “While the payment itself is not disputed, the article omits that it constituted legitimate deferred board fees earned for services rendered between January and March 2025 and approved in terms of the company’s Delegation of Authority,” she contends.
- Moreover, the article further omits to report that she voluntarily forfeited approximately R2 million in board fees during her tenure to prioritise employee salaries, company liquidity and animal welfare.
- She provides me inter alia with correspondence, dated 21 August 2025, confirming that she forfeited a payment of R1 988 367 in unpaid Board fees.
‘She has been appointed to the audit committee of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme, but with the scheme’s recent history, she might wish she were back on the farm.’
- Segooa complains that this statement links her appointment to the NSFAS Audit and Risk Committee to the Daybreak narrative, implying that her appointment was undeserved or inappropriate. “It omits that I was appointed through prescribed NSFAS governance process based on my qualifications and experience as a qualified Chartered Accountant [CA(SA)] and governance professional.”
- To support her claim, she provides me inter alia with an appointment letter by NSFAS, dated 25 May 2026.
Relief sought
- Segooa requests that I find against the publication and direct it to apologise, retract and correct those mistakes.
Reply to the complaint
In general
- Rose replies that:
a. the text appears in the News & Fox section of the Financial Mail, a weekly diary column which includes a brief “good week for / bad week for” format. Readers recognise this column as comment, not news reporting, and the item is “presented in a manner that it appears clearly to be comment,” as Clause 7.2 of the Code requires;
b. Segooa’s role as interim chairperson of a company majority-owned by the Public Investment Corporation (custodian of the Government Employees Pension Fund), and her subsequent appointment to the Audit and Risk Committee of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (“NSFAS”), are matters of legitimate public interest;
c. no malice is alleged; and
d. every material fact relied upon is either expressly admitted by Segooa or corroborated by the annexures she has herself filed.
In particular
The caption
- Rose says it is common cause that Segooa resigned from Daybreak Foods and that it was “with immediate effect”. He contends that such a resignation (i.e.: no notice period) is in fact abrupt. Besides, the text does not suggest any impropriety on her part. Moreover, the use of the word “dumbstruck” describes her colleagues’ presumed reaction to a sudden departure. “It does not comment on, still less impugn, her reasons for leaving,” he submits.
Overseeing the dire situation at Daybreak Foods
- Rose argues that “overseeing” a company as a chairperson “is not, and would not reasonably be read as, an assertion that she personally caused the Avian Influenza-related distress that predated her appointment”.
- He adds that Clause 7.2 of the Press Code requires comment to take fair account of the material facts underlying it – it does not require “a 90-word item to recite every mitigating circumstance a potential subject would wish included”.
- None of the supporting evidence that Segooa provided renders the facts relied upon untrue or unfairly presented, he argues.
R625 000 payout
- Rose notes that the amount of R625 000 is not in dispute.
- He argues that the use of the word “payout” is “standard, neutral journalistic usage for a sum received on departure and does not, of itself, impute impropriety”.
- Moreover, the reference to “the scandal” reflects the well-documented fact, as evidenced by Segooa’s own supporting evidence – Daybreak Foods was at the relevant time the subject of Hawks/DPCI criminal investigations into fraud and theft by other senior office-bearers.
- He contends that the text places her departure within that period – “it does not allege, and could not reasonably be read to allege, that she was implicated in that fraud”.
- In conclusion, he says that the R2 million which Segooa forfeited concerns a different and later claim. “Its omission from a passing reference to the earlier R625,000 payment does not render that reference inaccurate or unfair.”
Appointment to the Audit Committee of NSFAS
- The editor denies that the reference to Segooa’s appointment implies that it was inappropriate.”
- He says the text does not comment on the process by which she was appointed to the NSFAS Audit and Risk Committee, on whether the position was advertised, or on her qualifications for that role. What it does comment on is the well-documented and widely reported recent history of NSFAS itself, an organ of state currently under statutory administration. That is a matter of legitimate public interest, and comment on it is squarely protected by the provisions of Clause 7.2 of the Press Code.
Conclusion
- Rose says that Segooa seeks a fuller and more sympathetic account of her tenure at Daybreak Foods than a 90-word satirical diary-style entry is designed to carry. “The Code does not require that. It requires that comment be grounded in facts that are true or reasonably true, made without malice, on a matter of public interest, and presented as comment. The item satisfies each of those requirements.”
Rejoinder
In general
- Segooa replies that the Financial Mail’s submission is premised on a fundamental misreading of Clause 7.2 of the Press Code. She denies that she is seeking a “sympathetic account” – she says she is merely asking for a “fair” account, as is required in that clause of the Code.
- She says the crux of her complaint is not about accuracy – it is about material omissions that create a diametrically opposing impression of her conduct. “It is these material omissions that render the comment unfair and in breach of the Code.”
- Segooa says she accepts that the text is comment and not hard news.
- She submits several arguments about the nature of satire.
- She contends that her response should be read against the Financial Mail’s earlier reporting on the same subject matter, which was published on 12 May 2025. (I am not considering this, as it has no bearing on the present complaint.)
In conclusion
- Segooa summarises that her complaint is about the impression that the text projects that she:
a. irresponsibly abandoned a failing company, rather than to depict her as a director who was forced to resign due to severe and documented personal safety risks;
b. was responsible for the company’s collapse, which unfairly impugns her professional competence. The evidence shows she inherited a crisis and acted to mitigate it within the context of her very short tenure; and
c. enriched herself and acted improperly. She says the full context shows the opposite: personal financial sacrifice and a commitment to ethical governance.
35. She concludes that she does not ask this office to decide whether the words used are individually defensible, or whether the item’s tone is permissible as satire. “It asks whether the comment, taken as a whole, has taken fair account of all material facts, [that are] true or reasonably true. On that test, the item falls short in the … respects identified in the original complaint, and it does so as part of a pattern rather than as an isolated lapse.”
Analysis
The caption
- In dispute are the statements that Segooa resigned as chairperson “with immediate effect” and that it left fellow board members “dumbstruck”.
‘With immediate effect’
- The complaint is that Segooa resigned abruptly, while the article omits material facts relevant to that inference.
- Rose’s argument on this issue is sound. The words in question imply that her resignation was “abrupt”. Given the size and the nature of the text, I also do not believe that the “facts relevant to that inference” were material to the fact that Segooa did resign with immediate effect.
‘Dumbstruck’
- The Merriam-Webster thesaurus describes the word “dumbstruck” as “stunned, affected with sudden and great wonder or surprise. Synonyms are inter alia “amazed”, “shocked”, “astonished” and “appalled”.
- However, whichever way one looks at it, “dumbstruck” implies that the other members of the Board did not expect it. That presupposes that they were not aware of the circumstances surrounding Segooa’s resignation. That, for me, is hard to swallow. Surely, they must have known about the documented security threats, intimidation and incidents affecting them as well (see paragraph 4 in this regard).
- But that is not all. Rose contends that the word “dumbstruck” describes her colleagues’ “presumed reaction” to a sudden departure. This, I believe, is plucked from the air. What gave the author of the text the right to “presume” their reaction? And to present this assumption as a fact?
- As I believe that the other Board members must have been aware of the dire situation, it follows that the use of the word “dumbstruck” cannot be true or reasonably true.
- I also consider that such a suggestion might have tarnished Segooa’s reputation unnecessarily.
‘Overseeing’ the financial train wreck of Daybreak Foods
- The complaint is that the:
a. use of the word “overseeing” implies that Segooa was to blame for the problems, while Daybreak Foods was already in severe financial distress, which was largely due to the industry-wide impact of the 2023 Avian Influenza outbreak, before her appointment; and
b. text omits to state that she served as interim chairperson for less than three months and that, during this period, the Board secured a successful TERS application to support employee salaries and resolved to place the company into Business Rescue to maximise the prospects of rehabilitation.
45. I agree with Rose that the use of the word “overseeing” does not imply guilt on the side of the chairperson, as documented under paragraphs 18 – 20.
46. I also do not believe that the omission to state that she was the chairperson for less than three months and that she had some success during that period can justifiably be seen as a breach of the Press Code.
A R625,000 payout
- The complaint is that:
a. this reference links the “payout” with her resignation and frames it as having been improper, as the text omits to report that the payment constituted legitimate deferred Board fees earned for services rendered; and
b. the text omits to mention that she voluntarily forfeited approximately R2 million in Board fees during her tenure to prioritise employee salaries, company liquidity and animal welfare.
48. The amount of R625 000 is not in dispute, the inference that it implies that the payment was improper, is.
49. I agree with Rose’s arguments, as documented under paragraphs 21 – 25 above. I do not see any need to repeat them here.
Segooa’s appointment at NSFAS
- The sentence in dispute reads, “She has been appointed to the audit committee of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme, but with the scheme’s recent history, she might wish she were back on the farm.”
- Segooa complains that this statement links her appointment to the NSFAS Audit and Risk Committee to the Daybreak narrative, implying that her appointment was undeserved or inappropriate, while she was appointed through prescribed NSFAS governance processes based on her qualifications and experience.
- I concur with Rose on this issue – there is no such implication. What it says to me, is that the situation at NSFAS is even worse than the one at Daybreak farm – nothing more, and nothing less.
- I also agree that the text does not comment on the process by which she was appointed to the NSFAS Audit and Risk Committee, and there is no indication that the appointment was suspect.
In conclusion
- The crux of Segooa’s complaint is not about the accuracy of the statements – it is about the question whether the column has taken fair account of all material facts.
- For that, I need to consider the purpose of the column. It was not to comment on the circumstances of Segooa’s resignation from Daybreak Farms, nor was it about the question whether her appointment at NSFAS was suspect. The main focus of the column was to highlight that Segooa’s new role at NSFAS could be even more difficult than the one she had encountered at Daybreak Farms.
- I need to add that I do not read into the text that Segooa irresponsibly abandoned a failing company, that she was responsible for its collapses and that she had enriched herself.
Finding
- The word “dumbstruck” in the caption is an assumption that was presented as a fact. This is in breach of the following clauses the Press Code that state:
a. 1.3: “…opinions … shall be presented clearly as such”;
b. 3.1: “The media shall exercise care and consideration in matters involving dignity and reputation”; and
c. 7.2: “Comment or criticism is protected … as long as it … has taken fair account of all material facts that are either true or reasonably true…”
- The rest of the complaint is dismissed.
Sanction
- Financial Mail is directed to publish an apology to Segooa for implying that her resignation from Daybreak Farms was out of the blue, while there were credible reasons behind her decision to leave the company. Those reasons should be mentioned, as documented in paragraph 6 above.
- The above should:
- be published at the earliest opportunity after the time for an application for leave to appeal has lapsed or, in the event of such an application, after that ruling;
- be published in print and on all platforms of the publication where the article was published;
- be published, with appropriate prominence, with the apology in the introductory sentence and with a headline including the words “apology” and “Segooa”;
- refer to the complaint that was lodged with this office;
- end with the sentence, “Visit org.za for the full finding”;
- be published with the logo of the Press Council; and
- be approved by me.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
28 August 2026
