Bojane Segooa v Maroela Media
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PCSA 000737
Author: Elisma van der Watt
Headlines:
- DA objects to Bojane Segooa’s new position (the article was written in Afrikaans and is headlined, DA maak beswaar teen Bojane Segooa se nuwe pos)
- Former Daybreak chairperson now at NSFAS (the article was written in Afrikaans and is headlined, Oudvoorsitter van Daybreak nou by NSFAS)
Publication Date: Both were published on 15 July 2026
Date lodged: 30 July 2016
Links to stories:
- https://www.google.com/search?q=DA+maak+beswaar+teen+Bojane+Segooa+se+nuwe+pos&sca
- https://MMmedia.co.za/nuus/sa-nuus/oudvoorsitter-van-daybreak-nou-by-nsfas
PARTICULARS
- This finding is based on correspondence received from Bojane Segooa and from Wian Spies of Hurter Spies Incorporated, on behalf of Maroela Media (henceforth: “MM”).
The articles
The first story
- DA higher education spokesperson Dr Delmaine Christians has reportedly criticised Segooa’s appointment to lead NSFAS’s audit and risk committee, arguing that it could undermine public confidence in the scheme.
- Segooa previously chaired Daybreak Foods, where she received R624 843.51 shortly before resigning amid a major governance and financial crisis. At the time, Daybreak workers reportedly went unpaid while management continued receiving salaries, and thousands of chickens faced starvation. An NSPCA court action also addressed alleged inhumane treatment of the birds. An investigation into her payment is still ongoing.
- Christians is quoted as saying that Segooa’s previous role raises questions about the judgment behind her NSFAS appointment, particularly because NSFAS itself has struggled with governance problems. The DA plans to question Higher Education Minister Buti Manamela in Parliament about:
a. what due diligence was done before her appointment;
b. whether her Daybreak record was considered;
c. whether the position was publicly advertised;
d. how many candidates were considered and what criteria were used;
e. whether he knew about or approved the appointment; and
f. whether he believes the appointment improves NSFAS governance and public trust.
The second report
- This text carries most of the information that is reported in the first article and aims to provide background information.
- It adds Segooa’s comment that she forfeited nearly R2 million in Board fees to prioritise employee salaries and animal welfare.
- NSFAS reportedly defended Segooa’s appointment, citing her audit and risk expertise and the qualifications of the committee. However, NSFAS acknowledged that Mathebula was unaware of the investigation when he appointed her. Mathebula has said he will seek advice, potentially including a legal opinion, to decide what action should be taken.
THE COMPLAINTS, DEFENCES, REJOINDER AND MY ANALYSES
- Note that some of these complaints concern only one article, while others have to do with both reports.
GROUND 1: Misrepresentation of governance chronology and role at Daybreak Food
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the text inaccurately reports that she was appointed in May 2024 on an interim basis to lead the Board following the 2023 avian flu outbreak. She says she joined the Board as a non-executive director in May 2024 and only assumed the role of interim chairperson of the Board on 7 February 2025 (serving approximately two months in that non-executive capacity).
- She argues that the conflation of her non-executive Board tenure with her stint as interim chairperson creates the false and unfair impression that she was the primary executive authority throughout the entirety of Daybreak’s operational challenges.
- She provides me with documented evidence, confirming that she was notified that she had been appointed as:
a.chairperson of the audit committee of Daybreak Farms on 4 June 2024; and
b. interim chairperson of the Board of Daybreak Foods on 7 February 2025.
The defence
- MM acknowledges that it has made a “limited chronological error”: Segooa indeed was appointed to the Board’s audit committee in June 2024 but only became interim Board chairperson on 7 February 2025.
- However, the publication argues that the mistake was not significant enough to justify a full retraction or an unconditional apology. Spies says that the underlying point, that Segooa joined Daybreak’s Board after the company was already experiencing financial difficulties stemming from the 2023 avian-flu outbreak, remains accurate.
- Furthermore, the article does not suggest that Segooa caused the financial crisis, that she exercised executive control from May 2024, or that she was responsible for problems that predated her interim chairperson role – the article expressly states that the financial crisis existed before her tenure as interim chairperson.
- MM points out that this office upheld News24’s identical date error under Clause 1.1 of the Press Code but expressly found it irrelevant and immaterial because Segooa was the interim chairperson when the payment, worker unrest and animal-welfare proceedings occurred. The same should apply in this instance.
The rejoinder
- Segooa notes that MM accepts that its article contains a mistake regarding her tenure at Daybreak Foods and contends that it attempts to minimise this as immaterial because the key events allegedly occurred during her tenure as interim chairperson.
- She says this defence is untenable. “Compressing a tenure that began in a non-executive capacity in May 2024 into a period of interim leadership starting in February 2025 is a material distortion, not a minor imprecision.” It falsely presents her as the primary executive authority throughout the entirety of Daybreak’s crisis, when in fact she held this role for only approximately two months. She submits that this mistake fundamentally misrepresents the scope of her authority.
My analysis
- In my finding about the same issue (the complaint was against News24), dated 15 August 2026, I wrote: “The question … is whether this mistake has caused her unnecessary harm. In this case, I do not believe so. She resigned on 7 May 2025 – approximately three months after being appointed as interim chairperson of the Board. At the time, she received a payout of R625 000; there were unpaid worker strikes; and an urgent court order obtained by the NSPCA concerning starving chickens at the producer’s facilities. The question of when she was appointed as chairperson of the Board is therefore irrelevant and immaterial.”
- The same applies to this case.
GROUND 2: Misleading framing of the R624 843.51 payment
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the article misleadingly insinuates that she “secured a payout of R624,843.51 for herself” prior to her resignation as it implies that she improperly enriched herself.
- She submits that the money was a valid, legitimate payment for services rendered long before she resigned on 7 May 2025. The payment was in fact for work done from 1 January to 31 March 2025, she says.
- She contends that the article utilises this (legitimate and valid) payment as a primary basis to quote the DA criticising her morals and her suitability for public office.
The defence
- MM points out that the fact of the payment is not disputed. Moreover, the articles do not describe the transaction as unlawful, unauthorised, fraudulent, a severance payment or a windfall. The text also does not assert that Segooa determined the payment unilaterally or breached a delegation-of-authority framework.
- The publication adds that the second article refers to Segooa’s own explanation that all payments received by her were for services rendered. Her preferred additional explanation is therefore not a correction of a false statement; it is further context on a fact already reported together with her position.
The rejoinder
- Segooa calls MM’s argument that the articles did not describe the payment as unlawful and included her explanation that it was for services rendered “disingenuous”. She says her complaint is not about the literal words used but the prejudicial framing. The Afrikaans phrase “het vir haarself ‘n uitbetaling … verseker” (secured a payout for herself), juxtaposed with imagery of corporate collapse, unpaid workers, and starving animals, creates a powerful inference of improper self-enrichment.
- She concludes: “Including a single line of her explanation does not cure the harm caused by the omission of the full context: that the fees were contractually earned, deferred by Board resolution to preserve cash flow, and paid months after the period in which they were earned.”
My analysis
- The disputed statement in the first article reads as follows: “She secured a payment of approximately R624,843.51 for herself in May last year before resigning from Daybreak Foods”.
- However, Segooa is correct in that this issue should not be dealt with in isolation – the context of this payment is as important as the disputed text. Lower down in the article, it is reported that, at the time of her resignation, “ordinary workers” waited for payment and “thousands of broiler chickens suffered from hunger”.
- Given this context, the central question is whether reasonable readers would have inferred from the article that she had enriched herself improperly.
- I do believe that there is such a possibility – especially because the article does not report that the amount was for services rendered some months before her resignation.
- But there is an even broader context that I need to consider – the second article was published on the same issue, by the same author and on the same day. That article does refer to Segooa’s explanation why she was remunerated. This does bring some needed balance to the reportage.
- Seen together, coupled with the fact that the amount of R624 843.51 is not in dispute, I do not believe that reasonable readers would have understood that the payment was improper.
- I also note, with interest, that Segooa does not complain about the statement in the second story that there was an ongoing investigation into the payment. This raises red flags for me – why is there an inquiry into the matter if everything is above board?
GROUND 3: Material omission of approximately R2 million in forfeited Board fees
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the article omits to report that she had forfeited approximately R2 million in legitimate Board fees to prioritise worker salaries and animal welfare costs during the liquidity crisis (adding that Board members were remunerated only after all other creditors had been paid). She argues that, omitting this substantial financial sacrifice while highlighting a single fee payment, creates a misconception of her priorities.
- She provides me with documented evidence, inter alia confirming that she forfeited an amount of approximately R2 million (which she was legitimately owed).
- “Omitting this substantial financial sacrifice while highlighting a single fee payment creates a biased characterisation of her priorities,” she concludes.
The defence
- MM replies that this omission is not material to either article’s core subject, because it does not unfairly change the core story.
- “Omitting the forfeiture did not render the undisputed R624 843,51 payment false or leave Segooa’s position wholly unrepresented, because her services-rendered explanation was included,” Spies submits.
The rejoinder
- Segooa submits that, omitting the fact that she forfeited the money, “is a distortion of the highest order”. This, she argues, paints a picture of greed where the full facts demonstrate financial sacrifice for the company’s benefit.
My analysis
- I agree with MM on this issue. I do not see why the omission in question should have been reported and how the neglect to do so could have constituted a breach of the Press Code.
GROUND 4: False association with operational failures (Board v management)
The complaint
- The complaint is that the reportage unfairly portrays Segooa by associating her with animal welfare failures, worker exploitation, and business rescue, while omitting her role in addressing those issues.
- She provides documentary evidence showing that she initiated and led efforts to secure TERS funding for workers, negotiate feed supplies, and investigate alleged management corruption, including matters referred to the Hawks. She also stresses that day-to-day operations were the responsibility of executive management, not the non-executive Board.
The defence
- MM replies that the reportage is about the company’s crisis and the temporal circumstances of Segooa’s resignation – it does not state that a non-executive chairperson personally performed day-to-day feeding, payroll or farm-management functions.
- MM says the articles do not claim that Segooa took no steps to assist.
- The phrase “bestuursmislukkings” (management failures) in the first article is attributed to Christians.
- MM expressly reported that Daybreak had struggled financially following the 2023 avian-influenza outbreak. The documentary material confirms that the outbreak significantly reduced production and increased input costs. “Thus, the very context said to be omitted was included.”
- Moreover, the articles do not say the Board or Segooa caused the financial distress.
The rejoinder
- Segooa says that, while MM did not explicitly state she personally managed farm operations, the relentless juxtaposition of her name and image with these failures creates that association for the ordinary reader.
- She adds that the articles fail to mention that the Board, under her leadership, was actively investigating other executives for the very fraud and mismanagement that contributed to these failures. This omission, she submits, unfairly attributes blame to her.
My analysis
- With respect, I believe that Segooa reads too much into the articles. They merely report a factual situation at the time of her resignation, without attributing the crises to her.
GROUND 5: Omission of critical context (2023 avian influenza)
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the article attributes Daybreak Farm’s insolvency to oversight failure by the Board and unfairly puts the blame of the operational collapse on administrative incompetence.
- She submits that, when she joined the Board as a non-executive director in May 2024, the company had already been crippled by the 2023 avian influenza epidemic, by depleted cash reserves, and by historical adverse audit findings.
- She adds that the Board successfully secured a R250 million PIC loan before eventually resolving to enter business rescue as a statutory mechanism to protect assets since that funding was insufficient to cover the needs of the business at the time.
The defence
- MM says it expressly reports that Daybreak struggled financially following the 2023 avian influenza outbreak. The documentary material confirms that the outbreak significantly reduced production and increased input costs. “Thus, the very context said to be omitted was included.”
- Also, the articles do not say that the Board or Segooa caused the financial distress. “Further detail about shareholder funding, the Land Bank facility, TERS efforts, the PIC drawdown or particular supplier disbursements could support separate reporting, but was not necessary to a report about a new NSFAS appointment and the DA’s objection,” Spies argues.
The rejoinder
- Segooa contends that MM’s defences “misinterpret the core duty of fairness”. She argues that a single, passing mention of the avian flu does not constitute taking “fair account” of all material facts when the rest of the article attributes the company’s entire collapse to the Board’s tenure.
My analysis
- There indeed is nothing in either article to suggest that Segooa was to blame for the avian influenza outbreak. Both texts merely accurately report a factual situation at the time of her resignation.
GROUND 6: Mischaracterisation of business rescue
The complaint
- Segooa says the second article depicts the company’s demise as a failure under the watch of the Board, while the decision to put it under business rescue was a deliberate, legal governance decision taken by the Board under the Companies Act to prevent liquidation and protect jobs in an insolvent business which was inherited by the Board.
- This, she complains, “frames a statutory restructuring tool as a personal governance failure”, and disproportionally puts the blame on her.
The defence
- MM replies that the statement that Daybreak entered business rescue after approximately R1.95 billion had been invested by the PIC over about 20 years was accurate. “No ordinary reader would understand Segooa, who joined the Board in 2024, to be responsible for two decades of investment decisions.”
- Besides the articles do not say that business rescue was unlawful, that the resolution was irrational, or that Segooa personally caused it.
The rejoinder
- Segooa replies that framing business rescue (a proactive, statutory governance decision taken to protect the company from liquidation) as a failure, is a “material distortion”.
My analysis
- I agree with MM on this issue. Why would Segooa be responsible for decisions that were taken long before her tenure? I do not believe that reasonable readers would have come to such a conclusion.
GROUND 7: Misleading inferences surrounding resignation motives
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the statement that she “resigned days before” animal welfare court rulings creates an inference that she fled accountability or litigation.
- Instead, she says, she resigned because of grave personal safety threats, explicit death threats, and intimidation directed at her and her family following her exposure of internal corruption. These incidents were formally reported to the South African Police Service.
The defence
- MM says it reported chronology, not motive – the articles did not state that Segooa resigned because she had anticipated the NSPCA ruling, or that she had fled accountability, or that she had sought to avoid operational responsibility. Reporting the resignation before the court ruling did not imply an evasive motive. The same reasoning should apply to MM Media, particularly as it used milder wording.
The rejoinder
- Segooa calls the MM’s defence “disingenuous” – juxtaposing her resignation with an animal welfare court ruling “actively invites the reader to infer a causal link: that she fled accountability”. She contends that drawing an inference of a false motive while omitting the actual, documented motive (namely, grave and reported death threats against her and her family) constitutes a material omission “of the highest order.” In her view, that omission fundamentally distorts the narrative, recasting a whistleblower acting under duress as a director seeking to evade responsibility.
My analysis
- The article accurately reports that Segooa resigned days before an animal welfare court judgment. It also does not expressly link her resignation to that ruling.
GROUND 8: Misleading framing of the NSFAS appointment
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the following statement is inaccurate and unfair: “[She] … was recently appointed to … NSFAS to lead the agency’s audit and risk committee.” The article quotes Christians as saying she is concerned that Segooa’s position at NSFAS “was allegedly not publicly advertised”.
- She submits that she was appointed as a committee member and that that position did not legally require public advertising. This “exaggerates [my] operational role at NSFAS and falsely implies procedural illegality regarding [my] appointment.”
- She provides me with documentary evidence, dated 25 May 2026, that she was appointed as an independent member of the NSFAS’s audit and risk committee, and that her position could be filled without advertising the post.
The defence
- MM says it did not report that Segooa was appointed to lead or chair the NSFAS’s audit and risk committee, nor did it state as fact that the appointment was unlawful or irregular – the first article merely reported the DA’s objections and questions.
- Spies adds that the articles did not state, as fact, that her position had to be advertised. “The demanded ‘correction’ would therefore correct a statement MM never made.”
The rejoinder
- Segooa replies that MM’s argument that it did not report that she was appointed to lead that committee is demonstrably false.
My analysis
- MM is wrong on this issue – the second article does report, in the second sentence, that Segooa was appointed “to lead the [NSFAS’s] audit and risk committee”. That is indeed “demonstrably false”, as a relevant document reveals.
GROUND 9: Failure to distinguish fact from opinion / prejudiced comment
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the following statement by Christians is prejudiced: “Segooa’s tenure at Daybreak has become synonymous with one of the country’s most serious governance failures.” She contends, “While political criticism is permitted, publishing extreme opinions built upon an incomplete, distorted factual foundation violates fair comment standards.”
The defence
- MM replies that the statement was attributed to the DA, and that it was not presented as a fact.
The rejoinder
- Segooa argues that attribution does not excuse MM from reporting fairly and accurately.
My analysis
- MM had all the right in the world to publish Christians’s comment – if it did not state the allegation as fact.
GROUND 10: Headline misrepresentation and cumulative distortion
The complaint
- Segooa complains that the headlines contribute to the prejudicial narrative – they could link her to corruption, the starvation of chickens, and to financial distress, while omitting all exculpatory evidence.
The defence
- MM argues that the headlines accurately represent the content of the articles, as required by the Press Code.
The rejoinder
- Segooa replies that MM’s defence relies on an atomistic reading of its articles, defending isolated phrases while ignoring the cumulative and materially false impression created by factual inaccuracies, egregious omissions, and unbalanced reporting.
My analysis
- This part of the complaint has no legs to stand on. Both headlines accurately reflect the content of the articles.
GROUND 11: Failure to afford a reasonable opportunity to respond
The complaint
- Segooa contends that the reportage was damaging to her reputation and dignity, and that MM therefore should have given her an opportunity to respond. She submits, “Republishing historical quotes from older media reports does not fulfil the Clause 1.8 requirement to allow the subject to respond to new, specific article framings prior to publication.”
The defence
- MM says it accepts that Clause 1.8 generally requires the views of a subject of critical reportage to be sought if practicable. The present context, however, includes that the:
a. article primarily reports a publicly issued political statement;
b. assertions were clearly attributed;
c. no new covert allegation was presented as MM’s own finding; and
d. background article referred to Segooa’s publicly recorded version regarding her payments.
The rejoinder
- Segooa replies that the failure to seek her comment constitutes a “substantive, not merely procedural, failure”. Had MM approached her, she would have furnished it with the evidence of the death threats, the fee forfeiture, the Hawks’ investigations she initiated, and the correct timeline. “Its failure to do so ensured its report would be one-sided and inaccurate. This was a critical failure of basic journalistic ethics.”
My analysis
- The issue whether MM should have given Segooa a right of reply will be settled by the question whether she was the subject of critical reportage, as stipulated by Clause 1.8 of the Press Code – and not by its arguments as documented under paragraph 85.
- The first article clearly raised questions about her integrity – rightly or wrongly. This means that MM should have given her an opportunity to respond to the allegations made against her.
- The second article does quote her, albeit briefly.
POST SCRIPT
- MM has raised questions about Segooa’s translation of the two articles from Afrikaans to English. Afrikaans is my mother tongue, and I am satisfied that the translations do not alter the essence of the matters reported on. I do not believe that anything was lost, or changed, in translation.
FINDING
- The fact that MM did not afford Segooa a right of reply prior to publication is in breach of Clause 1.8 of the Press Code that states, “The media shall seek, if practicable, the views of the subject of critical reportage in advance of publication, except when they might be prevented from reporting, or evidence destroyed, or sources intimidated. Such a subject should be afforded reasonable time to respond; if unable to obtain comment, this shall be stated”.
- The statement in the second sentence of the second report that Segooa was appointed to “lead” NSFAS’s audit and risk committee is inaccurate. This is in breach of:
a. Clause 1.1 of the Press Code which states, “The media shall take care to report news truthfully, accurately and fairly”; and
b. Clause 3.3 of the Press Code that states, “The media shall exercise care and consideration in matters involving dignity and reputation.”
93. The rest of the complaint is dismissed.
SANCTION
- MM is directed to:
a. apologise to Segooa for the breach of the Press Code as documented under paragraph 92; and
b. give her a right of reply in that apology of a wording not longer than 300 words.
- The above should:
- be published at the earliest opportunity after the time for an application for leave to appeal has lapsed or, in the event of such an application, after that ruling;
- be published in print and on all platforms of the publication where the article was published;
- be published, with appropriate prominence, with the apology in the introductory sentence and with a headline including the words “apology” and “Segooa”;
- refer to the complaint that was lodged with this office;
- end with the sentence, “Visit org.za for the full finding”;
- be published with the logo of the Press Council; and
- be approved by me.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
2 September 2026
