Zuraya Adhikarie v Netwerk24
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PCSA 000700
Author: Almari Wessels
Headline: Weggedobbel of wanbestee? Parlement swyg oor casino-kongres (Lost in gambling or mismanaged? Parliament silent on casino congress)
Publication Date: 16 June 2026
Date lodged: 7 July 2026
Link to story: https://www.netwerk24.com/nuus/aktueel/weggedobbel-of-wanbestee-parlement-swyg-oor-casino-kongres-20260615-0805
Particulars
- This finding is based on correspondence from the former Chief Legal Adviser to Parliament, Adv Zuraya Adhikarie, and from Henriëtte Loubser, the editor of Netwerk24.
The article
- The article deals with Parliamentary expenditure of more than R10 million on the Brics conference that was held at Emperors Palace in 2023, of which R6.8 million was later declared as irregular expenditure by the Auditor-General.
- In the only reference to Adhikarie in the otherwise quite lengthy report, she is quoted as saying (on 6 April 2024): “The only question for me is whether we received this service. My understanding is that we have. Consequently, the service provider must be paid. Our internal processes are not their problem. Am I missing something? I am obliged to respond to the attorneys on Monday, failing which the STP will be facing litigation.”
The complaint
- Adhikarie complains that the reportage (the article, the headline and a picture of her) is unfair and misleading in that it:
a. falsely associates her with wasteful expenditure and wrongdoing;
b. selectively quotes her correspondence;
c. omits critical legal and Auditor-General context;
d. uses a biased source without adequate verification; and
e. fails to seek her comment despite identifying her.
5. She submits that she was not involved in the matter and only became involved later to provide conditional legal advice on Parliament’s statutory payment obligations.
6. “By identifying me by name and publishing my photograph, the publication places me squarely within that narrative and creates the impression that I was connected to, responsible for, or implicated in the conduct suggested by the headline,” she argues.
7. She concludes that the reportage has caused her significant reputational harm.
Relief sought
- Adhikarie requests that Netwerk24:
a. correct the mistakes;
b. apologise for failing to obtain her comment prior to publication;
c. publish the corrections and apology with appropriate prominence;
d. amend the headline, sub-heading and online presentation of the article to remove any unfair implication that she was associated with, responsible for or involved in the conduct suggested by the headline;
e. amend the online version of the article to incorporate the omitted material facts, including the Auditor-General’s findings and the context of her legal advice;
f. remove or appropriately qualifies material that unfairly associates her with procurement decisions, expenditure approvals or misconduct.
9. In later correspondence, she adds some further requests.
Reply to the complaint
- Netwerk24 denies that the reportage is in breach of the Press Code, mainly because:
a.the article is about Parliament’s R6.8 million irregular expenditure and not about Adhikarie;
b. she is mentioned only to report her position in a later dispute over payment, and not to accuse her of any wrongdoing;
c. her statements and the financial irregularity are supported by documentary evidence and official records, particularly the Auditor-General’s finding;
d. it did attempt to obtain her response or that of Parliament;
e. the graphic was intended to illustrate various officials’ views about whether the R6.8 million should be paid;
f. the article does not portray her legal opinion as wrong – her position was simply reported alongside the contrary views of former CFO Jason O’Hara and Secretary to Parliament, Xolile George;
g. the R6.8 million being classified as irregular expenditure was an established Auditor-General finding, independently reflected in Parliament’s own records, rather than an allegation by Netwerk24; and
h. the article did not need to explain the detailed statutory or legal framework behind Adhikarie’s advice because the legal merits of her opinion were not the subject of the article.
Rejoinder
- Adhikarie submits that I should consider the cumulative effect rather than each element separately. She says she was named, professionally identified, photographed, selectively quoted, placed in a graphic concerning “wasted millions”, juxtaposed with the former CFO’s opposing position, not personally contacted, incorrectly assumed to remain a parliamentary employee, and denied the opportunity to provide material context. She contends that the narrative is sufficient to mislead the public.
- According to her, the relevant question is not whether the article expressly accused her of causing the expenditure – it is whether the overall portrayal of her in connection with serious allegations about public expenditure was fair, accurate, balanced, properly verified and contextualised.
- Adhikarie concludes that the proper questions are whether the manner in which she is presented is fair and contextual; whether material information is omitted; whether doubtful or incomplete information was adequately verified; and whether she should have had a right of reply.
Analysis
- Adhikarie is correct in arguing that the reportage could have breached the Press Code, even though she is not the focus of the article. That is why I am taking her complaint seriously.
- As the story is about Parliament’s R6.8 million irregular expenditure, I do not believe that she has the standing to complain about the gist of the report – that is for Parliament to complain about. I am therefore not adjudicating the merits or demerits of the article as such.
- She can, though, complain insofar as the reportage involves her in the matter.
- The central question is whether the reportage portrays her in a negative light, either directly or by implication, or by what is reported or what could have been suggested. In other words, was she the subject of critical reportage?
- I do not believe so. There is no indication or implication whatsoever in the reportage that she was associated with, responsible for, or involved in procurement decisions, expenditure approvals or misconduct of any kind. The reportage about her is neutral – it merely records what her response was. The mere publication of her picture, the headline and her words do not in any way suggest that she was guilty of anything.
- As she was not the subject of critical reportage, Netwerk24 was under no obligation to give her a right of reply.
Finding
- The complaint is dismissed.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
10 September 2026
