City Power v News24
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PCSA 000747
Author: Kyle Cowan
Headline: City Power spin doctor Mangena implicated in tender interference, dirty tricks campaign
Publication Date: 24 May 2026
Date lodged: 3 June 2026
Link to story: https://www.news24.com/investigations/city-power-spin-doctor-mangena-implicated-in-tender-interference-dirty-tricks-campaign-20260523-1011
- PARTICULARS
- This finding is based on correspondence from Isaac Mangena, City Power (CP) spokesperson, and from News24’s investigative reporter, Kyle Coman, its head of investigations, Pieter du Toit, and its public editor, George Claassen (henceforth: “Claassen” and “News24”)
The article
- The introductory sentence reads, “… Mangena is implicated in apparent tender interference at the Joburg Fresh Food Market, according to a report by a law firm.”
- He allegedly introduced his “friend”, Mothepe Mangena, “who runs a Limpopo-based company called Mmirwa Power, to CP official Marvin Baepi.”
- The article “further reveals that Mangena and his colleagues are behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting a News24 investigative journalist, Khaya Koko, who has, for the past two years, reported on corruption at CP.”
- Witness Mazanga, a “charismatic” pastor, also reportedly falsely implicated Koko in an affidavit in an alleged extortion racket.
B. THE COMPLAINT
Background
- News24 argues that the complaint cannot be understood in isolation because it arose from a toxic CP power struggle in which untested allegations were allegedly used to discredit journalist Khaya Koko, and that Mangena’s complaint is an extension of that campaign.
Complaint 1 – Presenting an alleged “disinformation campaign” as an established fact
- The sentence in dispute reads, “News24 can further reveal that Mangena and his colleagues are behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting a News24 investigative journalist.”
- CP complains that this statement is presented as a factual conclusion rather than as an allegation or an interpretation – without citing any independent investigation, judicial finding, disciplinary process, forensic report, or law-enforcement finding to substantiate it, and despite CP having rejected the allegation. Mangena says that the journalist has already characterised the conduct as a “disinformation campaign” in correspondence prior to having asked for comment.
Complaint 2 – Publication of a serious allegation against Portia Motsepe, without adequate substantiation
- At the centre of this part of the complaint is the following sentence: “And according to another newsroom source at one of South Africa’s most revered weekly titles, a subordinate of Mangena’s, Portia Motsepe, provided the affidavit and a briefing to a reporter there.”
- The complaint is that this statement directly implicates Motsepe in the alleged circulation of an affidavit to members of the media, while the allegation is attributed solely to an unnamed source, without the information having been corroborated.
- CP submits that the allegation is unsupported by any disclosed documentary or corroborating evidence, leaving readers unable to assess the source’s reliability or motives. Despite the serious reputational harm to the named employee, the article presents the allegation as a fact, while withholding the evidence said to support it.
Complaint 3 – Misleading association between Isaac and Mothepe Mangena
- Central to this part of the complaint is this statement: “Mangena, the (law) report sets out, introduced his ‘friend’, Mothepe Mangena, who runs a Limpopo-based company called Mmirwa Power, to City Power official Marvin Baepi.”
- CP complains that News24 repeatedly associates Isaac Mangena with Mothepe Mangena, even though it also states that it “is unclear whether the two Mangenas are related”.
- It says that this creates a strong impression that Isaac Mangena had an improper relationship with the contractor and that this relationship influenced procurement processes.
- Importantly, CP continues, the article itself acknowledges that there is no conclusive evidence that Mangena manipulated the procurement outcome. The article therefore relies on inference and suggestion rather than established facts. CP submits that this approach encourages readers to draw conclusions that are not supported by the evidence presented.
Complaint 4 – No distinction between allegations, interpretations and established facts
- CP says a recurring feature of the article is the presentation of allegations and interpretations as factual conclusions. In addition to what is documented under the first complaint, examples include assertions that its officials or executives were:
a. responsible for disseminating information to media houses;
b. engaged in a coordinated campaign against Baepi; and
c. involved in efforts to discredit one another.
17. These allegations are presented “with a level of certainty that is not justified by the evidence disclosed in the article”.
Complaint 5 – Failure to present CP’s position fairly and in a balanced manner
- CP complains that, although some of its responses were included, the article gives greater prominence to the journalist’s allegations and conclusions than to its explanations – which resulted in an unbalanced account.
Complaint 6 – Misleading headline
- The headline states City Power spin doctor Mangena implicated in tender interference, dirty tricks campaign.
- CP complains that this misleadingly presents disputed, unsupported allegations as established facts – while the article itself provides no such evidence. The headline therefore conveys a stronger degree of established wrongdoing than the article’s evidence justifies.
Complaint 7 – Unfair reputational harm
- CP complains that the article seriously damages its reputation and those of the individuals named by presenting serious allegations as established wrongdoing, despite the fact that no competent authority has made any findings against them.
Relief sought
- CP asks for:
a. a correction, clarifying that the alleged “coordinated disinformation campaign” was not an established finding by any competent authority;
b. a withdrawal or clarification of the allegation concerning Motsepe, unless the publication can demonstrate that the allegation was independently verified in accordance with accepted journalistic standards;
c. its views to be published with appropriate prominence; and
d. an apology for any findings determined by the Ombud to be inaccurate, misleading, unfair or inadequately substantiated.
C. REPLY TO THE COMPLAINT
Complaints 1 and 4 – Presenting an alleged “disinformation campaign” as fact; no distinction between allegations, interpretations and facts
- News24 replies that the complaint is based on a misquotation of the article – Mangena omitted part of the sentence, including the crucial context that the alleged disinformation campaign targeted its journalist Khaya Koko, who had reported extensively on corruption at CP.
- Claassen argues that the full statement is truthful, accurate and fair, that it provides sufficient context, that it is balanced, and that it meets the standard of presenting only what could reasonably be true.
- He rejects Mangena’s claim that it needed an official finding from a court, investigation, disciplinary process, forensic report or law enforcement agency before reporting on the alleged campaign.
- News24 argues that:
a. the article resulted from its own investigative reporting, which can legitimately involve drawing conclusions from available evidence;
b. Mangena himself publicly commented on allegations in an affidavit that were still under investigation, so it is inconsistent for him to demand a much higher evidentiary standard from News24;
c. requiring a formal finding prior to publication would make investigative journalism impossible and could take months or years;
d. it was only fair to investigate and respond to allegations that were being widely circulated and that allegedly implicated Koko; and
e. the article was presented as its investigative response, intended to protect Koko’s dignity and News24’s reputation.
Complaint 2 – Publication of a serious allegation against Portia Motsepe, without adequate substantiation
No denial, no response
- Claassen notes that there is no actual denial of Motsepe’s role in the dissemination of the affidavit. “Similarly, when pressed to deny this allegation directly prior to publication, no such denial was forthcoming.”
- Such a direct denial would have played a role in the editorial decision to name Motsepe, he contends.
Anonymous source
- Claassen says that the complaint appears to focus mainly on identifying News24’s anonymous source, which it refuses to disclose.
- He submits that the article does not breach any clause of the Press Code because:
a. the Press Code permits the use of an anonymous source;
b. the journalist took steps to corroborate the source’s information – he/she “reached out to Mr Koko to warn him of the efforts to discredit him and (he) was motivated by collegial respect and a long friendship with Mr Koko”;
c. News24 is not obliged to provide details that allow readers to assess the source’s reliability, credibility or motives, as revealing too much could compromise the source’s anonymity;
d. it was reasonably true that Motsepe was involved in disseminating information about the Mazanga allegations to journalists;
e. the story was presented in context, fairly and accurately, without distortion, exaggeration or material omission; and
f. it did not present as fact that Motsepe briefed a journalist – it clearly attributed that information to an unnamed source.
Complaint 3 – Misleading association between Isaac and Mothepe Mangena
- Claassen submits that the article accurately reflects the findings of the KMA report. That report states that Isaac Mangena introduced his friend, Mothepe Mangena of Mmirwa Power, to CP official Marvin Baepi in connection with the Joburg Market solar tender.
- The article attributed this information to the KMA report and explicitly notes that it was unclear whether the two Mangenas were related. The report also states that the information about the introduction came from Baepi.
- He adds that the statement that there was no evidence that Mangena manipulated the tender outcome was a direct quotation from the KMA report and does not contradict its finding that his conduct was contrary to good governance.
- In conclusion, Claassen maintains that Mangena has never directly denied the allegation. He says he refused to cooperate with the KMA investigation and did not respond to News24’s questions. As a result, he says he considers KMA’s findings as established, while noting that Mangena himself is the person best placed to challenge or refute them.
Complaint 5 – Failure to present CP’s position fairly and in a balanced manner
- News24 submits that Mangena was given a fair and repeated opportunity to respond prior to publication, but that he failed to engage with the key allegations.
- Here are some facts:
a. It first sent questions to Mangena on 24 April 2026, received a vague response on April 29, and asked him to clarify it;
b. On May 12, it sent further questions after new information emerged, including the specific allegation that Mangena and CP were involved in a disinformation campaign; however, no response was received; and
c. It followed this up several times.
37. Claassen rejects Mangena’s claim that he had already denied the disinformation allegation, arguing that his earlier response addressed a different, narrower allegation about circulating the Mazanga affidavit.
38. He therefore maintains that Mangena’s right of reply was fully respected, and that his failure to provide evidence or engage with the follow-up questions cannot be blamed on News24.
39. News24 also argues that it was not required to disclose all its evidence prior to publication, provided there was sufficient evidence supporting the published claims.
40. Claassen concludes that News24 will be happy to report Mangena’s version of events, “if only he would be so kind as to actually provide his version.”
Complaint 6 – Misleading headline
-
- Claassen replies that:
a. the allegations are not “highly contested” (as the complaint goes), as Mangena:
i. did not participate in KMA’s investigation and ignored requests for consultation (which means that KMA had no version from Mangena on record to counter Baepi’s allegations against him);
ii. failed to respond to News24’s questions; and
b. the headline does not say the allegations have been established – it uses the word “implicated”, not “guilty”.
42. He submits that the headline accurately reflects the content of the article, as required by the Press Code.
Complaint 7 – Unfair reputational harm
- Claassen submits that News24 went above and beyond the requirements of Clause 3.3 of the Press Code to take care and be diligent in matters involving dignity and reputation. “We approached Mr Mangena and Ms Motsepe directly for comment on multiple occasions, recorded a half-baked ‘rejection’ immediately in the article after referencing Ms Motsepe and reported only what was in the public interest.”
- REJOINDER
In general
- CP submits that a distinction should be made between an investigative conclusion (which could read, “We investigated the circumstances and formed the view that a disinformation campaign occurred”) and a factual allegation (e.g. “Mangena and his colleagues are behind a coordinated disinformation campaign.”)
- Mangena argues that News24’s response shows that its conclusion is based on an inference drawn from several circumstances, including similar media reports, information from CP sources, social-media activity, and Mangena’s public comments.
- “The central criticism is therefore: evidence may support an inference, but an inference does not automatically become an independently established fact simply because it is based on an investigation.”
- CP says News24’s reasoning that it was “reasonably true” that there was a disinformation campaign and that Mangena and Motsepe were involved in it, demonstrates an inference which it transformed into an independently established fact.
- It adds that its submission is not that journalists may only report matters after a court judgment or official finding. The concern is that the article presents an allegation of deliberate deception as a sufficiently certain fact, without establishing the necessary basis for that conclusion.
- Mangena contends that the Press Code expressly recognises that allegations, rumours and suppositions may be reported but that it also requires that they be presented clearly as such. News24 could therefore have reported:
a. “News24 believes CP officials were involved in a coordinated disinformation campaign…”; or
b. “News24’s investigation indicates what it believes was a coordinated disinformation campaign…”; or
c. “Sources and other evidence reviewed by News24 suggest that…”, and back that up with some evidence.
50. Instead, the article states: “News24 can further reveal that Mangena and his colleagues are behind a coordinated disinformation campaign…”
51. The issue is therefore not the absence of a court order – it is about the degree of certainty with which the conclusion was presented by News24.
52. Mangena says he accepts News24’s right to protect confidential sources but argues that source confidentiality does not establish that the allegations were sufficiently corroborated. The concern is whether News24 had enough independent evidence to present serious allegations of deliberate deception and coordinated manipulation by named officials as fact. Given the severity of the allegations, CP says a higher standard of verification and contextualisation was required.
The complaint
Complaints 1 and 4 – Presenting an alleged “disinformation campaign” as fact; no distinction between allegations, interpretations and facts
- CP replies that its silence should not be treated as an admission of the allegations. It adds that News24 frequently imposes tight deadlines that can make meaningful responses difficult and potentially support a predetermined narrative.
- It argues that its 29 April 2026 response did, in substance, reject the alleged disinformation campaign, even though it did not use the exact phrase “disinformation campaign.” It explicitly rejected insinuations linking CP employees to the improper circulation of information and reaffirmed its commitment to proper governance, investigations and lawful processes.
- In fact, the article itself reported CP’s rejection, showing that News24 understood the response as a rebuttal.
Complaint 2 – Publication of a serious allegation against Portia Motsepe, without adequate substantiation
- CP says the allegation that Motsepe supplied an affidavit and briefed a reporter is based on an unnamed source, without adequately explaining how the allegation was independently corroborated.
- It rejects News24’s suggestion that Motsepe’s failure to directly deny the allegation amounted to corroboration.
- Mangena says the allegation was particularly serious because it was presented within the broader narrative of a “coordinated disinformation campaign” involving CP officials, potentially portraying Motsepe as participating in deliberate manipulation and reputational attacks.
Complaint 3 – Misleading association between Isaac and Mothepe Mangena
- By calling Isaac and Mothepe Mangena “friends”, the impression could have been created that they were relatives and therefore that nepotism could have been involved – even though the article does state it was unclear whether the two were related.
- Moreover, CP argues that News24 relied on a draft forensic investigation report that had not been officially released, and that the investigation itself was still incomplete. News24 nevertheless presented the KMA findings as established facts.[1]
Complaint 5 – Failure to present CP’s position fairly and in a balanced manner
- CP maintains that it did provide a substantive response on April 29. While it accepts that the response does not expressly use the words “disinformation campaign”, it clearly rejects the underlying allegation that its employees were improperly handling or circulating information outside established governance processes. The article did not provide that denial with sufficient contextual weight.
Complaint 6 – Misleading headline
- CP argues that News24’s reliance on the word “implicated” misses the real issue under Clause 10.1 of the Press Code – the question is whether the headline fairly reflects the evidence in the article and avoids creating a misleading impression.
- Mangena says the headline would likely lead a reasonable reader to understand that he was involved in serious wrongdoing, and not merely that his name appeared in a report, while the article itself states that the KMA report found no conclusive evidence that he had manipulated a procurement result.
- In other words, CP argues that the headline combined “tender interference” and “dirty tricks campaign” in a manner that conveyed a stronger impression of established wrongdoing than was supported by the qualifications contained in the article, including the KMA finding that there was no conclusive evidence that Mangena manipulated the procurement outcome.
Complaint 7 – Unfair reputational harm
- CP denies that News24 exercised equivalent care when assessing and presenting the allegations. It submits that the article made serious allegations against Mangena and Motsepe, and that seeking comment alone does not satisfy the obligation of fairness.
- Mangena concludes that the cumulative presentation of the allegations caused serious reputational prejudice and required a higher degree of care, particularly because named individuals were accused of dishonesty, improper influence, tender interference and participation in a coordinated campaign against a journalist.
- ANALYSIS
Complaints 1 and 4 – Presenting an alleged “disinformation campaign” as fact; no distinction between allegations, interpretations and facts
- I am combining my analysis of the first and the fourth complaints, for convenience’s sake, as News24 has grouped them together in its response to the complaint.
- Central to the first complaint is the following statement: “News24 can further reveal that Mangena and his colleagues are behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting a News24 investigative journalist, Khaya Koko, who has, for the past two years, reported on corruption at City Power”.
- Mangena writes in his complaint: “The article does not identify any independent investigation, judicial finding, disciplinary process, forensic report or law enforcement finding that establishes the existence of a coordinated disinformation campaign involving Mr Mangena or any City Power employees.”
- From this, I believe that this part of the complaint is twofold. It is about:
a. the mere existence of such a campaign; and
b. Mangena’s alleged involvement in it.
71. The fourth complaint is about assertions, presented as facts, that its officials or executives were:
a. responsible for disseminating information to media houses;
b. engaged in a coordinated campaign against Baepi; and
c. involved in efforts to discredit one another.
72. The relevant pieces in the article regarding these issues are:
a. “News24 can reveal that City Power officials, including in Mangena’s department, were responsible for sending the Baepi story to three national publications”; and
b. “The utility’s seniormost executives are involved in dangerous efforts to discredit one another…”
73. The question is whether the above-mentioned statements have breached Clause 1.3 of the Press Code, which requires the media to present only what may reasonably be true as fact, and to present opinions, allegations or suppositions clearly as such.
74. Let me say in passing that I do not agree with Claassen that the omission to refer to Koko’s reportage on corruption at CP is a misquotation. Yes, it would have given more context, but the omission does not materially alter the crux of the matter.
75. Be that as it may, the sentences in dispute are clearly opinion – which was not indicated as such, as they were stated as facts. Therefore, my adjudication of this matter rests on the question whether these statements can be deemed as reasonably true.
76. For that, I need to turn to the documentation provided to me to back up those claims.
Mazanga’s affidavit, dated 3 April 2026 (KC1)
- Mazanga names two CP officials in his affidavit, Marvin Baepi and Thabang Mashishi, as well as a News24 journalist (unidentified) as suspects in a serious case of harassment, extortion and corruption. Mention is also made of Rindzani Nkanyani, a “middleman” (or, more correctly, a “middle-woman”).
- He writes, “These individuals have been using extorted millions of rands from me threatening my life and kidnapping my kids… They operate a criminal syndicate, manipulating tender processes and targeting successful bidders for extortion and threats.”
- Seen in isolation, this affidavit cannot be used to justify the statement that Mangena was behind a disinformation campaign – his name is not even mentioned in the document. At best, it can be used to report an alleged case of harassment, extortion and corruption.
- Initially, I found it strange that News24 accepted Mazanga’s affidavit as reliable but then rejects his words in a taped telephonic conversation to the effect that Koko was involved in the scheme.
- I asked Claassen about this. He replied that News24’s internal review determined that the allegations against the journalist were not true. “This conclusion is based on a glut of information from Mr Koko himself, and our own internal records regarding his investigative work, including briefings to his editor and team members, as well as the timeline of these events. The decision to believe one above the other was not arbitrary. We examined Mr Koko’s role critically and in the specific context of Mr Mazanga’s allegations. It must also be seen in the context of Mr Koko’s own investigation into Mr Mazanga, which has already revealed significant malfeasance in his conduct with City Power contracts and employees. It is after this, including reviews of some of Mr Koko’s communications, that we then took the next step to ask the basic question: why are these allegations being made.”
- I have no reason to question the outcome of News24’s internal investigation into Koko.
- At this stage, my conclusion is twofold:
a. Because Mazanga’s affidavit has not been tested, his affidavit cannot be used to report, as fact, that there was malfeasance in CP. At this stage, it is only an allegation, which means that News24 could have reported it as an allegation; and
b. There is no evidence in this document that Mangena was implicated in anything untoward.
Some correspondence (KC2)
- Correspondence between various parties confirms the allegation of impropriety.
- Again, the correspondence concern allegations of wrongdoing; and no mention is made of Mangena.
Correspondence by Nkanyani (KC3)
- In this document, Rindzani Nkanyani, who was employed by CP, denies allegations that she had collected money from contractors and that she had been involved in improper tender-related activities.
- This means that there were such allegations – and therefore, that News24 was entitled to publish them as allegations (and not as facts).
- Again, there is no mention of Mangena.
Correspondence by Koko to the Auditor-General (KC5)
- This correspondence, dated 6 January 2026, is not helpful as far as this adjudication is concerned.
Correspondence between News24 and Mangena
- I have been provided with several correspondences, none of which make the claim that Mangena was behind a coordinated disinformation campaign. The claim that it was “reasonably true” that Mangena was implicated, can therefore not be based on this correspondence.
- There were indeed allegations against some CP officials were “behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting a News24 investigative journalist”.
- However, the fact that they are documented in an affidavit does not mean they are necessarily true – those allegations have not been tested.
Executive summary of the KMA report
- The only evidence regarding Mangena at my disposal is contained in the executive summary of KMA’s report. As this is important, I document the references to Mangena in that document in full:
a. “… Mangena advised [Baepi] that ‘his friend’ (referring to Mothepe Mangena) wished to apply to be awarded the contract”;
b. “This informal interaction is expressly flagged as ‘not in line with SCM policies and procedures’, as, by Mr Mangena’s conduct, he appears to attempt to undercut the SCM policy’s requirements for fairness and competitive integrity on behalf of Mmirwa”;
c. The document refers to a meeting in Mike’s Kitchen “between the then-CEO of City Power, Ms Tshifularo Mashava, Mr Isaac Mangena and [Mothepe Mangena]”; and
d. “Mr Mangena’s portfolio is not one where he would be involved in the recruitment process for a service provider in any capacity. His conduct breached ethical obligations requiring impartiality and avoidance of perceived or actual conflicts of interest, even though there is no conclusive evidence that he manipulated the procurement result.”
Conclusion
The first complaint
- I am satisfied that News24 was justified to report that, according to a KMA report, Mangena was implicated in apparent tender interference. However, I have not been supplied with any evidence that he was behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting Koko, stated as fact in the article.
The fourth complaint
- I have not been supplied with any evidence that News24 was justified to state, as a “reasonably true” fact, that CP officials, including in Mangena’s department, were responsible for sending the Baepi story to three national publications, and that CP’s seniormost executives were involved in dangerous efforts to discredit one another. Those were allegations.
Complaint 2 – Publication of a serious allegation against Portia Motsepe, without adequate substantiation
- The following sentence is in dispute: “And according to another newsroom source at one of South Africa’s most revered weekly titles, a subordinate of Mangena’s, Portia Motsepe, provided the affidavit and a briefing to a reporter there.”
- The central issues are:
a. whether News24 was correct in identifying Motsepe as the one who provided Mazanga’s affidavit to a reporter;
b. whether the reporter corroborated his information; and
c. the fact that the information was obtained from an unidentified, single source in a newsroom
98. Clause 11 of the Press Code reads, “The media shall protect confidential sources of information – the protection of sources is a basic principle in a democratic and free society; (the media shall) avoid the use of anonymous sources unless there is no other way to deal with a story, and shall take care to corroborate such information; and (the media shall) not publish information that constitutes a breach of confidence, unless the public interest dictates otherwise.”
99. I find it puzzling that Motsepe did not see her way open to deny the allegation made against her. A direct denial could indeed have played a role in the editorial decision to name Motsepe, as Claassen submits. This makes me think that the statement in dispute can indeed be reasonably true.
100. What is more, such a denial would also have made a difference to my adjudication. Let me explain why: If she denied it, News24’s information was either incorrect, or it has compromised the identity of an anonymous source. Considering the absence of a denial, I cannot find for the complainant. I am not so sure that Motsepe’s failure to directly deny the allegation cannot justifiably be seen as corroboration, as CP argues.
101. I need to add, though, that I am highly critical of a “source in another newsroom”. That person can say whatever he or she likes, without having to be held accountable. This reminds me of a finding that I have made on 10 May 2012 in the matter of Julius Malema versus The Sunday Independent. The article alleged that Malema’s house was worth R16 million – which he complained about. The newspaper’s defence was that other publications regularly mentioned that amount. I took the trouble to obtain an evaluation of the property by its architect. The amount was R8.5 million. Something is not true just because it is published somewhere – and in this case, just because the information came from a source in another newsroom.
Complaint 3 – Misleading association between Isaac and Mothepe Mangena
- The complaint is that the article creates a strong impression that Isaac Mangena had an improper relationship with the contractor, Mothepe Mangena, creating a narrative that suggests favouritism, undue influence or interference.
- I note that CP never stresses that the alleged impression was false. There is no denial that the two men were related, or that they were friends, nor is there any reason given why the association is misleading.
- Given that fact, I accept that the article was accurate and fair on this issue.
- In its rejoinder, CP argues that the report that News24 relied upon was only a draft (while the article itself states that the report has been “finalised”). I am not entertaining this issue, as it was not part of the original complaint. It would be unfair to make a finding about a matter which News24 did not have an opportunity to defend itself against.
Complaint 5 – Failure to present CP’s position fairly and in a balanced manner
- The complaint is that the article gives greater prominence to the journalist’s allegations and conclusions than to its explanations – which resulted in an unbalanced account. CP says its concern is not that News24 should have published the entire response, but that its substantive denial was not given comparable contextual weight to the allegations.
- I therefore now turn to the three times that Mangena did correspond with News24, which I have been supplied with.
- March 2026
- The questions posed by the journalist, to which Mangena responded, are not directly relevant to the article that is in dispute. For the record, these queries were:
a. Has CP received feedback for the Department of Home Affairs regarding its report exposing alleged identity fraud?
b. If no feedback has been received, has CP followed up with Home Affairs, and if not, why not?
c. With Charles Tlouane announced as Acting CEO, is the entity confident in his leadership, given the allegations raised?
d. Why did CP seemingly understate its losses related to the Shalazile Electrification Project, and has the Auditor-General been informed?
e. Is CP aware of alleged identity fraud, why are the individuals and companies still engaged with this entity?
109. They are not directly relevant to the gist of the article, which is about allegations that Mangena was implicated in tender interference. It is therefore of no use to me.
- April 2026 (correspondence to Cowan, the reporter)
- The gist of Mangena’s reply is that CP:
a. respects and encourages whistleblowing;
b. has established formal whistleblowing channels that allow for confidential and anonymous reporting;
c. gives its full cooperation with all lawful investigations; and
d. rejects the insinuation that it was associated with the handling or circulation of information outside of established governance processes.
111. Of those issues, only the last one is relevant to the article. And yes, it is reported – word for word.
April 29 (correspondence to Adriaan Basson and Pieter du Toit, with a cc to Cowan)
- Mangena mainly raises questions regarding the tone and nature of queries. He does not respond to any questions himself – which means that this document is also of no avail to me.
Conclusion
- I agree with Claassen that Mangena’s right of reply was fully respected, and that his failure to provide evidence or engage with the follow-up questions cannot be blamed on News24.
Complaint 6 – Misleading headline
- The complaint is that the headline misleadingly presents disputed allegations as established facts, implying that Mangena interfered in procurement and participated in a “dirty tricks” campaign – while the article provides no such findings and relies largely on allegations, unnamed sources and inference.
- Clause 10.1 of the Press Code reads, “Headlines … shall not mislead the public and shall give a reasonable reflection of the contents of the report or photograph in question.”
- This part of the complaint does not have a leg to stand on. The story is about a report by a law firm (whether that document was a draft or not) which, rightly or wrongly, implicated Mangena “in apparent tender interference”.
- I agree with Claassen in that the:
a. word “implicated” does not mean “guilty”; and
b. headline accurately reflects the content of the article, as required by the Press Code.
Complaint 7 – Unfair reputational harm
- See below.
FINDING
- The following statements of fact in the article should have been presented as allegations:
a. That Mangena was behind a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at discrediting Koko;
b. That CP officials, including in Mangena’s department, were responsible for sending the Baepi story to three national publications; and
c. That CP’s seniormost executives were involved in dangerous efforts to discredit one another.
Those are in breach of:
a. Clause 1.3 of the Press Code that says, “The media shall present only what may reasonably be true as fact; opinions, allegations, rumours or suppositions shall be presented clearly as such”; and
b. Clause 3.3: “The media shall exercise care and consideration in matters involving dignity and reputation…”
121. The rest of the complaint is dismissed.
SANCTION
- The above should:
a. be published at the earliest opportunity after the time for an application for leave to appeal has lapsed or, in the event of such an application, after that ruling;
b. be published in print and on all platforms of the publication where the article was published;
c. be published, with appropriate prominence, with the apology in the introductory sentence and with a headline including the words “apology” and “City Power”;
d. refer to the complaint that was lodged with this office;
e. end with the sentence, “Visit org.za for the full finding”;
f. be published with the logo of the Press Council; and
g. be approved by me.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
14 September 2026
[1] It will become clear in my analysis below why I have not documented the rest of CP’s quite elaborate arguments regarding the status of the KMA report.
