News24 vs Phillip Rakgwale
BEFORE THE APPEALS PANEL OF THE PRESS COUNCIL OF SOUTH AFRICA
In the matter between:
News24 Applicant
and
Phillip Rakgwale Respondent
Matter No: 00656/05/2026
DECISION ON AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
- This is an application by News24 (applicant) for leave to appeal the Ruling of the Acting Press Ombud dated 25 June 2026. The Ruling was on a complaint by Mr Phillip Rakgwale (respondent) lodged against the applicant about an article published on 16 April 2026, with the headline “Ekurhuleni millions: Questionable operations of shadowing company involved in toilet scandal.” The article was about a company that had won a tender with the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality about the provision of portable toilets. Certain allegations of irregularities were made regarding the tender. The respondent was the Group Chief Audit Executive of the City of Ekurhuleni. At the heart of the story was a probity report that had been prepared by the late City’s Chief Auditor, one Mpho Mafole who was allegedly assassinated soon after submitting his report. According to the respondent, this was a draft/preliminary report, provided to the respondent by Mafole. The report was considered and discussed by a management team. The report raised certain queries, while the final (team’s) report found no issues in the selection of the winners of the tenders in question. Here is the gist of the respondent’s point regarding the difference between the two, which distinction, he argued, the applicant failed to appreciate: “The preliminary report noted irregularities in disqualifying bidders, while the final probity audit found no issues with selecting winners. Each report addresses a different context: the former concerns both selected and disqualified bidders, the latter focusses on winning bidders only, disqualified bidders are excluded”.
- The above argument by the respondent was in answer to what was said of him in the article, namely, that he “immediately altered and sanitized the report’s findings, endorsing the probity of the three-year tender to station portable toilets across the metro municipality’s townships”; that is altering and sanitizing Mafole’s report. The respondent argument was, firstly, that the latter report was not sanitized, but considered and discussed by the respondent’s team (Mafole’s report was just a draft); secondly, the final report was the product of the team’s consideration of Mafole’s report and not just his. This brings to the findings in the Ruling.
- In his Ruling, the Acting Ombud held that:
- The applicant acted in breach of Clause 1.2 of the Press Code in that the applicant “should have, but did not, publish that the report was (by its own admission) a draft.”
- The applicant acted in breach of Clauses 1.1 and 2.2 of the Press Code, by singling the respondent “as the only one responsible for altering and sanitizing Mafole’s report, which decision was not taken by him alone.”
A sanction was imposed, in the form of apologising to “Rakgwale for singling him out as the only person who was responsible for altering and sanitising the report … causing him unnecessary harm”; secondly, the applicant was reprimanded “for not referring to the document on which it based its article as a draft report.”
- The applicant seeks leave to appeal the finding in paragraph 3.2 above. It argues that there was some overreach on the part of the Acting Ombud in that there was no complaint by the respondent that he had been singled out. For his part, the respondent says he supports the application for leave to appeal, but for a different reason. He is not a lawyer; his submissions must be taken to amount to a cross-appeal. While the applicant argues that there was in effect alteration and sanitization by him as the buck stopped with him, he denies two things: firstly, that there was any alteration and sanitization (of Mafole’s report), let alone acting by himself. All considered, there is only one point on which leave to appeal can be granted. It is this: Whether there was any alteration and sanitization of Mafole’s report; whether, whatever was done to that report, it was by Mr Rakgwale alone or was a team’s work.
- Leave to appeal is hereby granted for the Appeals Panel to consider the above point.
Dated this 17th day of August 2026
Judge B M Ngoepe, Chair, Appeals Panel
