Donovan de Klerk vs The Witness and South Cost
BEFORE THE APPEALS PANEL OF THE PRESS COUNCIL OF SOUTH AFRICA
In the matter between
Donovan de Klerk Applicant
and
The Citizen, The Witness and South Cost Respondents
Matter no: 000736/07/2026
___________________________________________________________________
DECISION ON AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
___________________________________________________________________
- Mr Donovan de Klerk (the applicant) failed before both the Public Advocate and the Acting Press Ombud in his complaint against the Citizen, The Witness and the South Cost publications (respondents) in respect of a series of articles by the latter over a period between June 2025 and February 2026. The complaint, it is common cause, was lodged when some of the articles complained about were more than a year old, with the most recent one being more than 5 months. A complaint is required to be lodged within 20 working days of the publication; his complaint was therefore grossly out of time. For that reason, the Public Advocate refused to accept it; his appeal to the Acting Press Ombud failed for the same reason. The applicant is now seeking leave to appeal the latter’s Ruling.
- The Public Advocate’s summary of the applicant’s explanation for the delay in lodging his complaint is that “the delay was caused by complex criminal proceedings, regulatory matters, dealing with journalists, providing evidence and instructing lawyers.” Yet, as the Public Advocate indicated, the applicant did have time to actively respond to the reporting, and could have therefore made time to lodge the complaint within the required period.
- The gist of the applicant’s explanation for the delay in lodging his complaint was also accurately summarized by the Acting Ombud in his Ruling dated 13 August 2026 as follows:
“The complaint concerns a series of related publications, journalists and recurring allegations over an extended period, rather than one isolated article. A proper complaint therefore required a consolidated review of the reporting, evidence and alleged breaches …. The circumstances were exceptionally serious and ongoing …”.
As demonstrated by the Public Advocate, the applicant could have found time to lodge his complaint. Also, the applicant’s argument that there was a series of publications – an argument he is repeating in his application before me – is not convincing; as the respondents correctly point out, the rules do not allow for an accumulation of complaints to be lodged later. The arguments raised by the applicant in his application add nothing new and do not take his case any further. The delay in lodging the complaint has simply been too long.
- The complaint has been lodged grossly out of time, without any adequate explanation; there are therefore no reasonable prospects that the condonation will be granted on appeal; the application is therefore dismissed.
Dated this 21st day of September 2026.
Judge B M Ngoepe, Chair, Appeal Panel
