Jurgen Nxumalo v News24 and Briefly News
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PCSA 000701
Author: Prega Govender
Headline: Sweeping floors with a chemistry degree: Debt denies 188 000 graduates certificates
Publication Date: 15 June 2026
Date lodged: 8 July 2026
Link to story: https://www.news24.com/southafrica/education/sweeping-floors-with-a-chemistry-degree-debt-denies-188-000-graduates-certificates-20260614-1036
Particulars
- This adjudication is based on correspondence from Jurgen Nxumalo and News24’s public editor, George Claassen.
Background
- Nxumalo says he approached journalist Prega Govender to request a public appeal for his active BackaBuddy crowdfunding campaign to clear his outstanding university fees at Durban University of Technology (DUT). He submits that his consent to be interviewed was entirely conditional on the publication of this campaign link to generate actionable public support.
The article
- The story is about 188 209 graduates who are unemployed because universities withhold their certificates over unpaid student debt.
- Nxumalo is one of them.
- Govender writes that Nxumalo “spends his days sweeping and cleaning his 73-year-old grandmother’s house”. He reports that Nxumalo launched a BackaBuddy crowdfunding campaign to settle his debt of R11 958 so that he could obtain the original copy of his diploma in analytical chemistry, without which he is not able to successfully apply for a job in his field of expertise.
- A picture of Nxumalo sweeping a yard accompanies the report.
The complaint
Fabrication of facts and staging (breach of Clause 1.1 and 1.10 of the Press Code)
- Nxumalo complains that the article falsely states that he is “informally employed as a floor sweeper”.
- He adds that the reporter rejected a video showing his home and academic certificates “because my grandmother’s house did not look run-down enough for his narrative”.
- He says that Govender asked him to pose for a picture of him sweeping the yard. He obliged because he was “under the impression it was for a general appeal”.
- The journalist then published his daily household chore (which he does out of care for his 73-year-old grandmother) and falsely labelled it as his “informal employment”.
- Furthermore, the journalist telephonically coached him to alter his written statements to “make it sad that I don’t eat nice meals” to maximise emotional exploitation for online clicks.
- Nxumalo concludes: “… the journalist deliberately suppressed my context, staged evidence, and fabricated an inaccurate narrative to publish a sensationalized ‘poverty piece’ that has deeply tarnished my personal and professional dignity.”
Suppression of academic merit, material mission (breach of Clause 1.2, 1.3)
- Nxumalo complains that the article omits “all material evidence of my academic excellence and proactive self-reliance to force a caricature of helpless poverty”.
- He says he provided the journalist with:
a. proof that he was a lifelong top-performing student, graduating Matric at the age of 16 and being a top achiever at the Heroes Academy: School of Maths and Science;
b. his 2019 award certificate for “Best Poster Presentation in Chemistry III” from the DUT Chemistry Department; and
c. proof of his efforts to clear his debt (he says he paid off R10 200 between May and July last year).
15. Nxumalo concludes, “The journalist actively suppressed these facts, removing my agency and academic identity entirely from the report.”
Omission of the core context (breach of Clause 1.2)
- Nxumalo complains that the publication excludes his BackaBuddy crowdfunding link, his contact details, or any means for readers to assist him, as it was agreed upon.
- He adds that, even though News24 admitted this mistake, it refused to remove the story, as he had formally requested.
Relief sought
- Nxumalo asks for “the complete and unconditional removal of the article and all associated social media posts from both News24 and Briefly News.
- Alternatively, he requests:
a. a public retraction and apology “acknowledging the factual inaccuracy regarding my employment status, the staging of the photo, and the suppression of my academic achievements”; and
b. an update to the article correcting his professional background, noting his independent fee payments to the DUT, and prominently featuring his active BackaBuddy campaign link “to restore the material context agreed upon prior to publication”.
Reply to the complaint
- Claassen says Govender conceded that he had mistakenly omitted the BackaBuddy reference from the story.
- He inter alia submits that:
a. the article was more generally about how many students are in a similar situation than Nxumalo and that the latter was not the main focus of the story. Therefore, Govender did not have to elaborate about how Nxumalo was addressing his student debts;
b. News24 tried its utmost to rectify the omission of the BackaBuddy campaign linked to Nxumalo’s name, which he rejected;
c. Nxumalo made all sorts of accusations against News24, even after he clearly indicated his satisfaction with the story in a WhatsApp message to Govender on June 17 (which was two days after publication);
d. Nxumalo himself supplied News24 with the picture of him sweeping the yard. He did not indicate any dissatisfaction with that in his thank-you WhatsApp to Govender;
e. Nxumalo refused to take calls from Govender and refused to provide his telephone number to him (Claassen) when he wanted to discuss a solution with him; and
f. the story did not tarnish Nxumalo’s reputation and dignity – instead, it was sympathetic towards him.
Rejoinder
- Nxumalo stands by his complaint.
- He replies that the omission of his BackaBuddy link distorted an active self-help effort into a sensationalized narrative without his informed consent.
- He says News24’s claim that he was “not the main focus of the story” directly contradicts the headline and argues, “News24 cannot use my image and identity as the primary hook for national coverage while dismissing my actual background as irrelevant.”
Analysis
- Allow me to state, upfront, that I am sympathetic towards Nxumalo’s personal situation. It must be extremely frustrating for him to have completed a diploma, only to learn that no original certificate could be issued – and to discover that, without that document, he cannot get employed in the field of his expertise.
- Having said that, I also need to state that I am not going to let my sympathy for him cloud my judgement.
- Firstly, Nxumalo complains that the article pictures him as being “informally employed as a floor sweeper”. That is simply not true. The article merely says that he is unemployed and that he “spends his days sweeping and cleaning his 73-year-old grandmother’s house”. Those statements, according to Nxumalo’s own testimony, are correct.
- Secondly, Claassen’s efforts to solve the problem are to be commended, while Nxumalo’s response to his attempts is baffling. Nxumalo himself gave News24 a choice between two alternatives. It chose one of them, offering that it would immediately update the article to prominently include his active BackaBuddy campaign link and contact details, as was originally the intention. Nxumalo then rejected News24’s acceptance of his own proposal.
- I interpret the omission to refer to his BackaBuddy as central to Nxumalo’s complaint. If he accepted News24’s offer to amend the article accordingly, it would have been the end of the matter.
- Even stranger is Nxumalo’s (positive) response to Govender two days after publication. He expressed his appreciation for the coverage and said he was grateful for that; he also thanked the journalist “for the time and effort you put into telling my story”.
- Regarding the “staging” part of the complaint: Unlike Nxumalo, I interpret Govender’s proposal to take a picture of him sweeping the yard, as well as commenting on what he and his grandmother ate as honest attempts to highlight his desperate plight.
- I also do not believe, not for a single moment, that Govender was dutybound to report details about Nxumalo’s academic achievements. The report says that he holds a chemistry diploma. That is sufficient.
- There is nothing in the reportage that could justifiably be seen as tarnishing Nxumalo’s dignity or reputation.
Finding
- The omission to publish Nxumalo’s BackaBuddy crowdfunding link, his contact details, or any means for readers to assist him is in breach of Clause 1.2 of the Press Code which says, “The media shall present news … without any intentional or negligent departure from the facts whether by … material omissions…”
- The rest of the complaint is dismissed.
Sanction
- News24 is directed to amend the article, as documented under Paragraph 34.
- The above should:
a. be published at the earliest opportunity after the time for an application for leave to appeal has lapsed or, in the event of such an application, after that ruling;
b. be published in print and on all platforms of the publication where the article was published;
c. refer to the complaint that was lodged with this office;
d. end with the sentence, “Visit org.za for the full finding”;
e. be published with the logo of the Press Council; and
f. be approved by me.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
21 September 2026
