News24 vs Maroela Media
Complaint 000746
Ruling by the Deputy Press Ombud
Date of publication:
26 July 2026
Headline of publication:
“Afriforum Antwoord op News24 se heksejag” (Afriforum answers to News23s witch hunt)
Link: AfriForum antwoord op News24 se heksejag – Maroela Media
Author: Kallie Kriel
Particulars
- A complaint was lodged on 4 August 2026 by George Claassen, News24’s public editor, on behalf of Adriaan Basson, the publisher’s editor-in-chief.
- Nico Strydom, editor of Maroela Media, responded on August 17.
- The complainant filed a rejoinder on August 21.
- On seeing the rejoinder, the respondent said it included new factual claims. They asked these either to be disregarded or to be allowed a further submission. The Public Advocate indicated that new claims would normally be disregarded, but that the respondent should file any further response to be on the safe side. This was submitted on 7 September.
- The complainant was given the opportunity to respond. Claassen denied there were new claims in their rejoinder but declined to respond further to the additional submission.
- I take into account the various submissions filed in this matter, though I have limited myself to the material and arguments relevant to the complaint as first filed.
The article
- The article by Kallie Kriel, the CEO of AfriForum, responds to critical reporting by News24 of the group’s financial affairs. It opens with the statement that News24 has now even teamed up with Julius Malema, leader of the Economic Freedom Fighters, to cast suspicion on AfriForum. (“News24 het nou selfs met Julius Malema hande gevat in ‘n poging om AfriForum onder verdenking te plaas.”)
- Referring to News24 journalists as “anti-AfriForum activists”, the piece argues the criticism merely serves to increase support for AfriForum while undermining News24’s own credibility. In its campaign against AfriForum, the news organisation has made mistakes for which they have had to apologise, Kriel writes.
- What Kriel describes as his organisation’s transparency is contrasted with News24’s alleged refusal to disclose financial details or remuneration. In addition, the questions being posed by News24 are not new, having been raised by Julius Malema before.
- The bulk of the article is devoted to an extensive description of how AfriForum spends the money it mainly receives from its members. The programmes are presented as a response to a failing state. Kriel defends its approach to remuneration and highlights a history of clean audits.
- An editor’s note at the foot of the article says that the contribution is by an independent person or company. The opinions are not necessarily those of Maroela Media. (“Hierdie plasing is deur ‘n onafhanklike persoon of onderneming saamgestel. Die menings en standpunte wat in hierdie skrywe uitgespreek word, is nie noodwendig die belyd of standpunt van Maroela Media se redakterus, direksie of aandeelhouers nie.”)
- A separate note identifies Kriel as the CEO of AfriForum.
The complaint
- The complaint refers to breaches of Clauses 1, 1.2, 1.3; 2.1, 2.2 and 2.3 of the Press Code.
Complaint: Independence: description of author as independent
Arguments
- The complainant says that the description of Kriel as an independent contributor is untrue, since he is a director of Maroela Media as well as a director of AfriForum’s investment arm, which in turn has a stake in Maroela Media. The complaint is that the publication is therefore in breach of Section 2 of the Press Code, which deals with the need for the media to be independent.
- The respondent says the article was clearly identifiable as an opinion piece by Kriel on behalf of AfriForum, with the headline, byline and tone of the article unmistakable. Nobody could have mistaken the article as the opinion of a neutral observer.
- Since the article is not about Maroela Media, a conflict of interest between his position as a company director and the article does not arise.
- The note identifying Kriel as independent simply indicated the column was not generated by Maroela Media’s own newsroom.
- The complainant, too, has written numerous opinion articles, the respondent says.
- The respondent also argues that section 2 of the Press Code is intended to prevent commercial interests influencing news coverage, of which there is no evidence. In this case, the article is an opinion piece.
- In a lengthy rejoinder, the complainant reiterates that Kriel cannot be described as independent, extensively pointing out the connections between Maroela Media, AfriForum and Kriel himself.
- The further submission by the respondent does not add any significant new points for consideration.
Discussion
- As the complainant rightly points out, Section 2 of the Press Code seeks to ensure that the journalistic media maintain their independence, avoiding real or perceived conflicts of interest. The main part of the provision reads:
The media shall not allow commercial, political, personal or other non-professional interests to influence reporting, and avoid conflicts of interest as well as practices that could lead readers to doubt the media’s independence and professionalism.
In Clauses 2.2, 2.3 and 2.4, three specific areas are highlighted: not accepting benefits that might influence coverage; declaring any support for the costs of newsgathering; and keeping editorial and advertising material distinct.
- The complainant has made no argument of relevance to Clauses 2.2 or 2.3 (and has not mentioned 2.4), so the complaint in terms of those provisions falls away.
- What remains is to consider whether the reference, in the editor’s note, to Kriel as independent can be seen more widely as creating doubt in the media’s independence and professionalism.
- There is no question that Kriel is entitled to write an opinion piece. The respondent is correct to argue that his links to Maroela Media do not preclude him from writing.
- The article as a whole leaves the reader in no doubt as to what it is: a strong response from AfriForum to critical reporting in New24. The heading says explicitly: “AfriForum responds to News24’s witch hunt”, and Kriel is identified as the CEO of AfriForum.
- The editor’s note stands as a contradiction to the overall tone and presentation of the article. Describing him as an independent contributor is simply inaccurate: his links to Maroela Media are extensive and undisputed. And the extensive links between the groups does render his relationship to Maroela Media relevant, even though the article itself speaks for AfriForum.
- The respondent argues that the editor’s note simply uses a standard formula indicating that an opinion piece does not come from the editorial team and does not necessarily reflect the newsroom’s view. The point is appreciated, though the difficulty with the unqualified use of the term independent remains.
Finding
- I find that Maroela Media breached Section 2 of the Press Code by inaccurately describing Kriel as an independent contributor.
Complaint: Unsupported claim: Teamed up with Malema
Arguments
- The complainant objects strongly to Kriel’s claim that they have teamed up with Malema, presenting a long list of reports as evidence of their critical attitude to the leader of the Economic Freedom Fighters.
- Though the article is an opinion piece, it is bound by the requirement in Clause 7.2 of the Press Code to take “fair account of all material facts that are either true or reasonably true”. The claim that News24 has teamed up with Malema is untrue, and so the article loses its protection as comment and must be judged in breach of Clauses 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3 which require accurate and truthful reporting.
- Some context for the claim is provided, in the form of statements that Malema has previously raised similar questions about the finances of AfriForum. But these come only 15 paragraphs into the article, while ethical codes require the context supporting a claim to be provided immediately.
- The respondent argues that the article is clearly identifiable as an opinion piece, with the complainants themselves describing it as such.
- The article therefore falls under Section 7, which protects expressions of opinion even if they are extreme, unjust, unbalanced exaggerated or prejudiced.
- The respondent describes the statement as rhetorical and polemical, not as an allegation of fact. Kriel was not alleging a formal agreement between News24 and Malema.
- In any event, some context to the statement is provided later in the article. The fact that it comes 15 paragraphs later is of no consequence: there is no formal requirement for the context to be presented immediately.
- In their rejoinder, the complainant argues that the statement about working with Malema is a factual claim, and the writer therefore needs to present evidence to back it up. In fact, News24 was raising questions about AfriForum’s finances before Malema, and the rejoinder includes a detailed argument about the sequence of events.
- The rejoinder also engages in some detail with the meaning of the expression “hande vat”, pointing to the fact that Kriel in a podcast used the English “teamed up” to make the same point about collaboration between Malema and News24.
- The supplementary filing by the respondents objects to several aspects of the rejoinder, arguing it introduces a materially different factual basis for the complaint.
Discussion
- At the core of the complaint is News24’s argument that the statement that they are co-operating with Malema is a factual claim that needs to be supported with some indication of evidence.
- In the original complaint, the complainant acknowledges that there is reference to Malema’s interest in the finances of AfriForum, but say it comes too far down in the article to provide support for the claim.
- As the respondents point out, however, there is no provision in the Press Code that sets out how soon after a claim the facts behind it must be presented. A general reference to ethical codes internationally is not sufficient to make the case.
- Elsewhere, the complainants are at pains to point out their questions to AfriForum predate Malema’s statements.
- The respondent argues that some of the material presented in support of the argument is new and should therefore not be taken into account, but it is in any case unclear how much it assists the complaint. Kriel’s statement alleges co-operation between the two – the question who came first does not emerge as central.
- The complainant also argues that News24 has a long history of critical reporting of Malema and the EFF. That record is not in dispute, but it does not disprove the possibility of an alignment, even active cooperation, on a particular issue.
- The complainant also draws attention to nuances of the Afrikaans language, interpreting the phrase as implying an active, close form of co-operation between News24 and Malema. The respondents, on the other hand, opt for an interpretation that is much looser, referring to “alignment, adoption or common cause”.
- The complainant points out that Kriel himself used the English term “teamed up” in another context.
- I note the respondents’ argument that the video where the term was used constitutes new material and would be a new basis for complaint. However, I refer to it only as a means to gain greater clarity on the Afrikaans term used in the article complained of. The video itself is not up for discussion.
- The respondents themselves acknowledge the English expression can be treated as relevant, and argue it can also be used rhetorically to describe broad alignment.
- The argument is persuasive. The overall tone and thrust of the article, particularly at the start where the claim is made, is rhetorical and the general reader would understand it as such.
- The relevant provision of the Press Code reads: “Comment or criticism is protected even if it is extreme, unjust, unbalanced, exaggerated …” It may be an exaggeration or unjust to claim collaboration between News24 and Malema, but the fact that both have been actively pursuing the matter provides sufficient basis for the claim.
- It is important to keep the door for robust debate as wide open as possible. The provisions that demand that opinion should be based on factual considerations should only be applied in very clear circumstances.
- The comment stands to be protected in terms of Section 7.
Finding
- I find that Maroela Media did not breach the Press Code by claiming that News24 has co-operated with Julius Malema.
Ruling
- The article breached Clause 2 of the Press Code by describing the author as independent.
- The rest of the complaint is
Sanction
- Maroela Media is reprimanded for breaching Section 2 and is ordered to amend the editor’s note to make it clear that Kriel is a director of the company. The note should make it clear that it has been amended in response to this ruling, and be published with the Press Council of SA logo and a link to this full ruling.
- The correction should be published as soon as is practicable after the expiration of the deadline for appeal.
- The wording and treatment shall be approved by me before publication.
Appeal
- The Complaints Procedures lay down that, within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at Khanyim@presscpouncilsa.org.za
Ruling by
Franz Krüger, Deputy Press Ombud
25 September 2026
