Appeal Decision: News24 vs Nomsizi Talane
BEFORE THE APPEALS PANEL OF THE PRESS COUNCIL OF SOUTH AFRICA
In the matter between
News24 Applicant
and
Nomsizi Talane Respondent
Matter no: 000679/06/2026
_______________________________________________________________
DECISION ON AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
___________________________________________________________________
- News24 (applicant) wants leave to appeal only certain findings by the Acting Press Ombud in his Ruling of 17 July 2026. It was a Ruling on a complaint filed by Nomsizi Talane (respondent) in respect of an article published by the applicant on 21 June 2026 with the headline “How Limpopo legislature’s secretary steered millions to a connected law firm.” The “connected” law firm is the respondent’s law firm; she is a director thereof. The essence of the story was that there was a familial relationship network on the basis of which millions were paid by the legislature to the respondent’s firm. The applicant argued that there was no breach of the Code; while the respondent argued that there were several clauses breached.
- I restrict myself to considering whether there are reasonable prospects of success on appeal regarding the findings complained about, namely,
- that the allegation of family ties was presented as a fact instead of an allegation; that this was therefore a breach of Section 1.3 of the Code;
- that the allegation that the firm’s appointment was during the same month that Maake took office was likewise a breach of section 1.3 of the Code.
- that there was a breach of Section 3.3 of the Code, because the article presented the above two crucial allegations as facts, thereby causing unnecessary harm to the respondent’s dignity and reputation.
The sanction imposed was an apology to the respondent. The applicant now wants leave to appeal the Ruling. For the application to succeed, the applicant must show that it has reasonable prospects of success. This is what I must determine.
- In its application for leave to appeal, the applicant points to the piece of evidence it alleges is critical to its case, namely, the family connections as depicted in the diagram it filed. The applicant argues that the Acting Ombud “failed to give adequate weight to the totality of this documented family network in his analysis”; it then goes into details in support of its argument. A finding in favour of the applicant could mean that the Ruling was wrong in concluding that what was reported was not factual. There are prospects that on appeal, the demonstrated familial relationship supports the applicant’s case. The issue of familial relationships was raised right from the beginning; family ties were mentioned, connections to Talane were alleged. In any case, this is an open appeal.
- There are other grounds of appeal: for example, that an apology was directed when there was no inaccuracy found, as well as finding the source to be trustworthy but ruling against the applicant.
- Back to the issue of family relations: this was raised by the applicant in its response to the complaint. It was said that the investigation established “a significant familial connection between a principal of the firm and the Legislature’s Secretary, Dr Timothy Maake.” There is also a section entitled “The familial/relationship link”. The issue is not, at this stage, whether the allegations are correct or not, but whether they may be found on appeal to be so. It is neither appropriate nor necessary to deal with all the points raised in the application; such details include the argument that the Acting Ombud confirmed that the source was reliable but still found a breach. Also, it is argued that the Acting Ombud focused narrowly on one family link and ignored the second independent link.
- I have noted the respondent’s response to the application, including to some of the issues raised; but those are matters to be argued on appeal.
The counter-application for leave to appeal.
- It is argued by the respondent that the Acting Ombud erred in three respects:
- That the CSD listing proves employment. It argued that the CSD is not proof of employment; that proof of employment should have been established. That is not how news reporting works; it is not a scientific exercise. The Acting Ombud had regard to context, and asked himself whether there was any reason to distrust the applicant’s information; that is, was there any reasonable basis to distrust the information. If the media were to report only on the basis of scientifically proven information, there would be no news reported. The Acting Ombud’s approach was correct, as it is clear from his analysis.
- With his finding that the word “steered” was justified. He set out the premise on which he came to this finding. What the respondents attempt to do, is to engage in a hair-splitting exercise and semantics.
- The Acting Ombud’s alleged failure to find that the applicant’s reliance on a single anonymous source was insufficient. There is no rule of thumb that one may not rely on a singly anonymous source; it depends on a number of circumstances such as whether there is documentary or other extraneous evidence. The Acting Ombud has sufficiently motivated his finding.
The counter-application for leave to appeal is therefore denied as it lacks reasonable prospects of success on appeal.
- In the circumstances News24 is granted leave to appeal the following three findings by the Acting Ombud, and the sanction imposed by him:
- that there is a breach of section 1.3 of the Code regarding the reporting of familial relationships;
- again, that there was a breach of section 1.3
- That there was a breach of section 3.3 based on the findings in 8.1 and 8.2 above.
Dated this 17th day of September 2026.
Judge B M Ngoepe, Chair, Appeals Panel
