Lighthouse vs News24
Complaint 000653
Ruling by the Deputy Press Ombud
Date of publication:
28 April 2026
Headline of publication:
“Company with no publishing history gets lion’s share of R1.6 bn publishing tender”
Author: Prega Govender
Particulars
- A complaint was lodged on 26 May 2026 by Georgia Groome, a director of the educational publishing firm Lighthouse Publishers. Following the Public Advocate’s advice, she submitted a revised version on 19 June.
- News 24 responded on 9 July 2026.
- The complainant filed a rejoinder on 16 July.
- I take into account the various submissions filed in this matter.
The article
- The article reports on the publication by the Department of Basic Education (DBE) of the catalogue of approved teaching materials and books for use in Grades 1 to 3. The report’s focus is on the success of Lighthouse Publishers, which was awarded just over a quarter of the titles included in the catalogue. The DBE list determines what provincial education departments may buy.
- The report highlights various indicators of the company’s status as a relative newcomer to the field of educational publishing. These include: that it was registered a few days after the contract specifications were published in 2024; that its registered address is a small cottage in Simon’s Town that belongs to the mother of the complainant; and that Groome’s co-director is a data science student currently based in China.
- The article contrasts the company’s success with the relative lack of success of much larger, older companies. People in the industry are quoted as questioning how the company could do so well when it lacks history and publishing infrastructure. One of them estimates the value of the award to Lighthouse at R285m.
- A table accompanies the article, showing the number of titles awarded to different publishers, showing how many more were awarded to Lighthouse than others. In the version initially published, only the top ten were provided.
- The article gives substantial space to responses from both Lighthouse directors, as well as Penelope Groome, who is Georgia Groome’s mother and the company’s senior development manager. Their account is that the company, though new, builds on the experience and uses the staff of the mother’s company, which has many years of experience.
- They say there is no need for extensive office and other infrastructure as staff work remotely and printing, warehousing and other functions will be contracted out. The listing of the cottage as registered address was simply an administrative solution.
- Staff are working without remuneration for the present, until the company generates income, they say. The Groomes are proud of their success, which they attribute to hard work and a quality submission, and point out that the process was based on a blind quality review. They also call the figure of R285m speculative.
- The article includes comment from the office of the minister, as well as from the departmental spokesperson, who emphasises that selection was done anonymously and defends the award to new entities.
- After publication, criticism emerged of News24 for failing to mention that Via Afrika, a sister company, had bid for a share of the catalogue, raising the possibility of a conflict of interest. In response, a note declaring the connection was added to the reporting, and the list of publishers expanded to include all beneficiaries, including Via Afrika.
- The complaint also refers to further reporting on the topic on News24, including a cartoon by the cartoonist Carlos on April 30 (https://www.news24.com/opinions/cartoons/cartoon-by-carlos-textbook-cottage-industry-20260429-0787). However, the complaint mainly refers to the report of 28 April.
The complaint
- The complaint refers to breaches of Clauses 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.7, and 1.8 of the Press Code. However, some elements of the complaint refer more appropriately to other sections of the code.
Complaint: Inaccuracy: use of term “tender”
Arguments
- The complainant says that the use of the word tender is inaccurate and misleading and creates an impression of impropriety. The process used in this case was not a conventional public tender, she says, but a blind quality review process.
- The respondent says this amounts to semantics, and that since the decision was competitive and at least partly based on price, the term is correct.
- In her rejoinder, the complainant denies it is a mere matter of semantics and says the fact that one source regarded the process as a competitive bidding process is insufficient to justify the use of the term. The fact that it was used only in the headline shows that News24 regarded the distinction as significant.
Discussion
- The respondent has made out a reasonable case for the use of the term. Though the complainant – and the Department of Basic Education (in statements such as this one) – goes to great lengths to argue that the process simply involved blind screening for quality and was therefore not a tender, the general reader would understand “tender” broadly to refer to any government process to procure goods or services. At its most general, a tender is simply an offer.
- Though tenders have come to be associated with corruption in South Africa, there is nothing in the term itself that necessarily suggests impropriety.
- The respondent claims (and the complainant then agrees) that the term is not used in the body of the text, but in fact it appears twice more. Even if it were only used in the headline, the argument that this is somehow significant is not persuasive.
Finding
- I find that News24 did not breach the Press Code by referring to inclusion in the catalogue of learning materials as a tender.
Complaint: Accuracy: the figure of R285million
Arguments
- In the context of the cartoon, the complainant objects to the use of the figure of R285 million as if it were fact. It is merely speculative, she says.
- The respondent does not specifically refer to the way the figure is presented.
- In her rejoinder, the complainant again references the presentation of a “speculative financial value as fact”.
Discussion
- The figure is an estimate offered by a publishing insider. The report also quotes Georgia Groome as saying the figure is speculative, and may be based on a very different business model.
- However, the first time the figure is used at the start of the introductory paragraph: “A publishing company that stands to make more than R285 million producing textbooks …”
- At that point, it is presented as fact, and the phrase “more than” suggests it is a minimum. The reader has to work their way some distance down the report before understanding where it comes from and that it is contested.
- The presentation here overstates the reliability of the figure.
Finding
- I find that News24 breached Clause 1.3 of the Press Code by presenting a source’s estimate of R285million as fact.
Complaint: Failure to disclose possible conflict of interest
Arguments
- The complainant says that News 24’s failure to disclose that a sister company, Via Afrika, was also a participant in the same catalogue process, and performed more poorly than in previous cycles, hides a potential conflict of interest. Readers should have been informed in order to judge whether the reporting was fair or may have been influenced, consciously or unconsciously, by a commercial motive.
- The respondent asserts that there was no contact with Via Afrika during the newsgathering process and points out that when criticism of its failure to disclose the connection was raised in another publication, the Daily Maverick, several steps were taken to address the matter. The News24 internal ombud, George Claassen, wrote a column, the graphic attached to the article was updated to include the full list of publishers involved and an acknowledgement of the connection was added. All further reports have made it clear that News24 and Via Afrika are both owned by Media24.
- In their rejoinder, the complainant argues that the corrections made represent an admission that the original article lacked important context, and do not repair the reputational damage they have suffered.
Discussion
- Though the complainant does not refer to it, the relevant clause of the Press Code is Section 2, which provides that the media should
not allow commercial, political, personal or other non-professional considerations to influence reporting, and avoid conflicts of interest as well as practices that could lead readers to doubt the media’s independence and professionalism;
- News24 should certainly have declared its connection with Via Afrika from the start. It is important to note that the Press Code provision does not only deal with actual bias, but also possible perceptions of bias.
- It is well established that transparency is important to forestall even the suspicion that coverage may have been shaped by non-editorial interests: in this case, the possible business interests of a related entity. News24’s explanations which aim to show that there was in fact no bias by highlighting the ways the journalist worked, where he is based and the like are not sufficient. It was important to be open so that readers could judge the story on the basis of full information.
- In any event, it is the publisher who has to take responsibility for the report, not the individual journalist.
- At the same time, it is also clear that News 24 recognised the problem and addressed it when criticism came to the fore. They deserve credit for having done so.
Finding
- I find that News24 breached Clause 2.1 by initially failing to disclose its connection to Via Afrika.
- Complaint: Material omission
Arguments
- The complainant raises several elements which should have been included, arguing that their omission left a misleading impression.
- First, the report should have mentioned that submissions were evaluated for quality on the basis of a blind process, which means that there could not have been anything improper about the selection of their materials.
- Second, the report should have mentioned the fact that over half of the entrants to the catalogue were new. Singling out Lighthouse was therefore unfair.
- Third, referring to the fact that the company was registered just before the process was announced was irrelevant, prejudicial and misleading as the terms of reference did not impose any conditions about how long an entrant had to have been in existence.
- Fourthly, reference to the company’s alleged lack of capacity, in terms of printing, warehousing or logistics was similarly irrelevant as this was not a requirement, and because publishers often rely on outsourced capacity.
- In response to the first point, the respondents point to a section of the article quoting the DBE spokesperson on the blind peer review process used, while Georgia Groome is also quoted on the process.
- In response to the second, the respondent says they did not know over half of the entrants to the catalogue were new. The focus on Lighthouse was justified by the fact they had been so very successful despite having little track record, and because other publishers were raising questions about their success.
- They justify the reporting on the basis that there is significant public interest in companies benefiting from the provision of educational materials.
- In response to the third point, News24 says they simply reported undisputed facts, which were that the company was registered just after the process was announced. The fact was confirmed by Groome, and the report also reflected her explanation that the company built on the success of her mother’s firm.
- On the fourth point, on the alleged lack of operational capacity, News24 again says the reporting dealt with undisputed facts. Groome’s explanations were also included.
- In her rejoinder, the complainant reiterates that some of the facts highlighted were not requirements in the procurement documents.
- She does not return to the question of whether the article dealt with the blind review process.
- In addition, the claim that the company has no publishing history failed to take into account the extensive experience of the individuals and entities behind Lighthouse, she argues.
Discussion
- The complainant argues that reference should have been made to the way in which the review process was carried out. In fact, the report does reflect the DBE’s description of the process, as well as quoting Groome on the matter.
- The complainant relies strongly on the fact that some revelations in the report are about things that were never required by the Department of Basic Education, including period of registration and the existence of operational infrastructure. These facts cannot be used to question Lighthouse’s credentials as they were never required, the argument goes, and not referring to the fact they were not required therefore materially distorts the report.
- The thrust of the report is that a relative newcomer did exceptionally well. In those terms, length of experience and operational capacity are certainly of interest, whether they were formally part of DBE conditions or not. I don’t feel the failure to mention the point is a critical omission.
- Though several other companies were new to the catalogue, Lighthouse’s particularly striking success justifies the focus on them. There was certainly significant public interest in the matter.
- Finding
- I find that the article did not breach the Press Code by omitting materially relevant information.
Complaint: Right of reply
Arguments
- The complainant argues that several important points were omitted from its reply. These were
- That Penelope Groom was never employed by the DBE;
- That the company works with a large network of contributors;
- That Georgia Groome has a background in education and educational development; and
- Other unspecified contextual facts.
- In response, the respondents concede that they did not specifically state that Penelope Groome was not employed by the DBE, but point out they did quote her as saying her professional experience did not give her privileged access to inside information.
- It points to the quoted statement that the team previously working for her mother’s company was now working for Lighthouse, which indicates the presence of a large team.
- And it notes a quote attributed to Georgia Groome alluding to her experience in educational material development.
- In her rejoinder, the complainant reiterates that materially important parts of her response were either omitted or reduced to a brief reference.
Discussion
- The article refers to the fact that Penelope Groom, through her own company, previously worked for the DBE. It does not explicitly say she was not employed there. However, it is not clear that it is essential information that she worked as a service provider rather than an employee.
- Though they may not have been given as much weight as the complainant might have liked, the other points were in fact mentioned in the report.
Finding
- The report did not breach the Press Code by omitting important points of the complainant’s reply.
Complaint: Prejudicial and sensationalist framing
Arguments
- At several points, the complainant argues that the article creates a narrative implying impropriety, favouritism and corruption. The cartoon by Carlos captures the narrative particularly clearly, using the speculative figure of R285m as fact, suggesting that the firm comes “from nowhere” and emphasising the establishment date of 2024 though it was not a requirement.
- In response, the respondent points to the fact that since the article appeared, several official inquiries have been launched into the process. The education authorities’ response shows that the reporting was clearly in the public interest.
- In her rejoinder, the complainant says that subsequent events can’t be used to determine whether the original reporting was compliant with the Press Code. Reporting had to be compliant at the time, irrespective of what happened afterwards.
- The complainant also says the respondents have not offered a response about the cartoon. Though she recognises the validity of satire, the cartoon draws on speculative and misleading information to create an impression that the company benefited improperly.
- Simply asserting that the reporting does not create an implication of wrongdoing is not enough, she says. The cumulative effect of the reporting is to paint her company as an “inexplicable newcomer whose success could reasonably be viewed as suspicious, despite no finding of wrongdoing having been made and despite the existence of substantial contextual information that would have allowed readers to reach a more balanced conclusion”.
Discussion
- The facts are in the main uncontested but are undoubtedly presented in a way that raises questions about the legitimacy of Lighthouse’s success. Criticism is expressed anonymously by several publishing sources and on the record by the African Publishers’ Association. The short history of the company, lack of infrastructure and other points leave the reader with the impression that there is something suspicious about their success. The Carlos cartoon captures that view sharply.
- At the same time, it must be conceded that an alternative interpretation is possible, one where a passionate, innovative group of relative newcomers submits quality work that simply outshines submissions by established players. Such an alternative interpretation was captured in the Daily Maverick’s report The DBE textbook story that South Africa is not being told. It was this story that first revealed the potential conflict of interest at News24.
- It is impossible at this stage to judge which version is accurate. Hopefully, the several inquiries now underway will provide some clarity.
- However, the question before me is not which version of the Lighthouse story is correct. It is whether the presentation of facts was fair, or whether material facts, or the company’s own account, were left out in such a way as to create significant distortion. I have to ask myself whether the facts as reported can legitimately sustain the interpretation placed on them.
- It is unquestionable that a great deal is at stake: educational publishers rely very heavily on state contracts, and their commercial success – perhaps even survival – depends on being able to find room in catalogues like this one. The stakes were all the higher because it was the first time in 14 years that the opportunity opened up. Publishers who did not make the cut, or lost share, would have every reason to be upset. The likely motives of the critics could have been given more attention.
- I accept the complainant’s position that the later launching of inquiries into the matter cannot be used as evidence that the reporting was reasonable. It has to be judged on its own terms.
- At the same time, the questions posed in the report remain legitimate. As outlined in the discussion above, I cannot find problems in the reporting that rise to the level of a breach of the Press Code.
- As far as the cartoon is concerned, it sharply captures the view that is put forward in the reporting. It is satire, the expression of an opinion, and should be given latitude as such. As was said in the settlement of another matter in 2025 (AfriForum and Solidarity vs Daily Maverick), a cartoon is “not literal but satirical”.
Finding
I find that the article did not breach the Press Code by prejudicial and sensationalist framing.
Ruling
- I find that the article breached Clause 1.3 of the Press Code by failing to make clear in the introduction that the figure of R285million was not uncontested fact.
- I find that the article, as first published, breached Clause 2 of the Press Code by failing to disclose a potential conflict of interest through its relationship with Via Afrika.
- The complaints that the article is in breach of other clauses of the Press Code are dismissed for the reasons outlined above.
Sanction
- News24 is ordered to amend the reference to R285 million in the intro to make it clear the figure is not uncontested. The change should be linked to the editor’s note, which should explain the change and reference this ruling.
- News24 is reprimanded for the initial failure to disclose the conflict of interest.
- The editors’ note should be expanded to also mention this reprimand, together with the Press Council of SA logo and a link to this ruling.
- The correction should be published as soon as is practicable after the expiration of the deadline for appeal.
- The wording and treatment shall be approved by me before publication.
Appeal
- The Complaints Procedures lay down that, within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at Khanyim@presscouncil.org.za
Ruling by
Franz Krüger, Deputy Press Ombud
3 September 2026
