Werner Human v News24
Ruling: Acting Press Ombud
Complaint number: PCSA 000759
Author: Kyle Cowan
Headline: Inside AfriForum’s money machine: How lobby group splurges on salaries, marketing
Publication Date: 26 July 2026
Date lodged: 11 August 2026
Link to story: https://www.news24.com/investigations/inside-afriforums-money-machine-how-lobby-group-splurges-on-salaries-marketing-20260725-0886,
Particulars
- This adjudication is based on correspondence by:
a. Wian Spies, a director at Hurter Spies Attorneys, on behalf of Werner Human, who is Solidarity Movement’s operational head and is complaining in his personal capacity (henceforth, “Human”); and
b. Kyle Cowan, investigative reporter of News24, Pieter du Toit, head of Investigations, and George Claassen, public editor of News24 (henceforth, either “News24” or “Claassen”).
The article
- The gist of the article is summarised as follows:
a. Afrikaner nationalist group AfriForum has earned R1.6 billion from donors and members between 2019 and 2024;
b. Expenditure on salaries and marketing outweighs spending on project delivery by far, financial reports obtained by News24 show; and
c. New memberships have fallen off a cliff since 2024; only 4 000 new members have joined in 2026.
3. The only references to Human in the report are documented immediately below.
The complaint
- Human complains that the following statements are inaccurate:
a. “News24 was however been able to establish the amounts some directors earned – including salaries of between R2 million and R3 million a year for some key directors”; and
b. “In the same vein, the remuneration of several other directors of AfriForum who work for the broader Solidarity Movement was revealed: Werner Human, the movement’s operational head, earned about R3 million a year, paid for by AfriForum.”
5. He adds that a graphic published together with the article, titled “Salaries of AfriForum directors and key staff”, highlights his name, stating that he was paid R3 309 797 in 2023 and R3 015 213 in 2024. The source of the reported information is indicated to be, “AfriForum financial statements”.
6.He says that, had News24 given him a right of reply, he “would have corrected the journalists’ misapprehension and the embarrassment and reputational harm could have been avoided”.
7. Human says the correct facts are that:
a. he is employed by the Solidarity Movement and that he is not an employee of AfriForum, as News24 intimates;
b. his remuneration is paid by the Solidarity Movement, and not by AfriForum as the article explicitly claims;
c. he does not receive any director’s fee, salary, compensation or benefit from AfriForum for serving as a nonexecutive director; and
d. his actual annual remuneration is not remotely close to R3 million.
8. He contends that the reportage has caused him considerable reputational harm and embarrassment because:
a. the report juxtaposes his salary with several leaders of AfriForum and the Solidarity Movement. It compares his salary to those of executive directors of AfriForum and claims that he earns more than any other leader mentioned. “This falsity naturally has the potential of causing workplace confusion, conflict, and uncertainty if any employee within the wider Solidarity Movement considers News24’s reportage as credible and accurate”;
b. he is singled out as part of the “splurge” of AfriForum on salaries. “The entire tone of the article is relevant as a reasonable reader would read the article as a whole”; and
c. he is pictured as a fat cat drawing a huge salary with money donated to AfriForum, ending up in the pockets of directors and key personnel rather than AfriForum’s programmes.
9. As evidence to support his claims, he submits confirmation by:
a. Anneri Leach, Head of Human Resources and Development at the Solidarity Movement Trust, dated 31 July 2026, that Human “has been a permanent employee of the Solidarity Movement Trust as Head of Operations since 1 January 2020 and to this date is still permanently employed by the Solidarity Movement Trust”; and
b. W A Vogel, Company Secretary AfriForum, that Human has not received any director’s fee, salary, or compensation from AfriForum, “or has been paid to him in the years 2023-2024, as reported by News24”.
Breaches of Press Code, relief sought
- Human complains that the article is in breach of Clause 1.1, 1.2 and 1.8 of the Press Code, all of which constitute a Tier 2 offence in terms of the Complaints Procedures.
- He requests an apology and correction to be published with the same prominence (same day and time of the week on the main page and on all social media platforms where the story was advertised). The original article also ought to be updated with a disclaimer at the top of the article.
Reply to the complaint
Employed by AfriForum?
- Human complains that the article falsely intimates that he is employed by AfriForum.
- Claassen denies that. He refers to the following statement in the report: “In the same vein, the remuneration of several other directors of AfriForum who work for the broader Solidarity Movement was revealed: Werner Human, the movement’s operational head, earned about R3 million a year, paid for by AfriForum” (his emphases).
- “This shows that the article correctly reports Human’s position as an employee of the Solidarity Movement and as a director of AfriForum,” he submits.
Remunerated by AfriForum?
- Referring to the following two “critical pieces of evidence”, News24 refutes Human’s contention that he is not paid by AfriForum:
AfriForum’s own documentation
- Claassen submits:
a. Human’s name appears in the 2024 Annual Financial Statements (AFS) for AfriForum under Note 22 to the statements on page 25, under the heading “Directors’ remuneration”. Underneath this heading is a further heading: “Executive”. Moreover, under a subheading “Services as director or prescribed official” Human’s name appears underneath that of Alana Bailey, a director of AfriForum since 2005, for the 2024 period. Directly underneath this, is the same information for the 2023 period;
b. The 2023 AFS does not reference or report on directors’ remuneration at all, which he (Claassen) believes is the reason for the 2024 report containing information for two financial years in this category. The reporting in Note 22 of the 2024 AFS, therefore, does not represent a mistake, or error. There was a deliberate effort to report directors’ remuneration for two financial years. That is why Human’s name appears twice. While he is a non-executive director, the report states he was remunerated for services as an executive director or “prescribed official”
c. The figures in the 2023 AFS looked redacted, but they were still technically present in the document, and News24 was able to uncover them. The figures revealed after completing this exercise were directly reported by News24 as total remuneration paid to Human for 2023 and 2024, being R3 015 213 and R3 309 797 respectively; and
d. “While Mr Human may wish to deny the amounts as accurate, he certainly was paid by AfriForum – or AfriForum contributed to his remuneration considerably. News24 submits the amounts are, however, accurate, for reasons that will be expanded on below,” he concludes.
Comment from Flip Buys, head of the Solidarity Movement
- On 21 July 2026, News24 asked Buys to confirm the nature of the R665 127 paid to him over 2023 and 2024, as contained in the 2024 AfriForum AFS.
- Claassen says Buys confirmed on 23 July 2026 that:
a. he was the chairperson of the Solidarity Movement;
b. the Movement is an umbrella body overseeing various organisations, such as AfriForum;
c. administratively, the Movement is a trust called the Solidarity Movement Trust;
d. the Trust does not generate its own funds; and
e. the Solidarity Movement is therefore “funded by the various institutions that are members of the Movement”.
19. He says this means that the Trust, which Human confirms is his employer, does not generate funds, and is reliant on organisations in the Movement for Funds. This includes AfriForum.
20. Moreover, Buys confirmed the practice and purpose, as well as the accuracy of the amounts in respect of himself.
In conclusion
- Claassen submits that Human “has failed to explain adequately in his complaint any relevant information or facts that dispute the content of AfriForum’s 2024 annual financial report, or indeed, why his name would appear in the report at all if he was not being paid by AfriForum”.
- He argues that Human could have checked the reports himself. If News24 got the figures wrong, he could have pointed them out in his complaint. However, he did not do so – instead, he “simply asks the Press Ombud to take it on faith that the amounts reported are wrong and elects not to deal with the evidentiary basis on which News24 relied at all”.
- To demonstrate the obviously close relationship between Human and AfriForum, he announced on 17 August on his social media pages that he had been appointed as Deputy CEO of AfriForum, an executive position at AfriForum.[1]
The amount of R3 million
- In response to Human’s complaint that his remuneration was not remotely close to R3 million, as the article states, Claassen says News24 obtained AfriForum’s 2020–2024 AFS from an intermediary on 18 December 2025, who had obtained them directly from the Department of Social Development (DSD) on 17 November 2025.
- The relevant 2024 report is dated 19 June 2025, while the auditor’s report is dated 18 July 2025. As a registered non-profit company, AfriForum is required to file its annual reports with the DSD, apparently within nine months after the end of its January–December financial year.
- “This means the report obtained by News24 is the version as it was filed with DSD by AfriForum – including the obscured amounts on pages 25 and 26. This means that the amounts were obscured/redacted before the report was filed with DSD,” Claassen submits (his emphases).
- Then, on 26 July 2026, the day the article was published, AfriForum CEO Kallie Kriel contacted Cowan. He disputed the salary figures published in the article, which is why they had been removed (he said). Cowan replied that he could only correct the figures if AfriForum supplied him with the correct information. He added that Buys confirmed the amount attributed to him.
- Claassen says it is noticeable that Kriel disputed the amounts, but not the identities of the people listed as having been paid.
- He argues that Kriel’s explanation for the redaction is implausible. Why redact the “incorrect” amounts, and not rather correct them? Likewise, if Human had been incorrectly listed as a recipient, why was his name not redacted?
- Furthermore, he submits that Human’s failure to address this issue in his complaint is significant. Is it because he may be withholding information that would establish the accuracy of the reportage to mislead the Press Ombud.
- He also questions what further verification Kriel or Human expected from it when the figures came from AfriForum’s own annual financial reports filed with the DSD, which Kriel had publicly described as accurate and as having been accepted by the DSD and SARS for approximately 20 years.[2]
- But there is more. Claassen notes that AfriForum uses Logista as its auditors, “which by all accounts is a reputable firm that conducts audits on various Solidarity Movement entities”. He opines that it is doubtful that an “error” of this nature would escape the auditors.
Submissions on paragraphs 6 – 14 of Human’s complaint
Paragraph 6
- Claassen says Human’s statement that he does not know where the specific figures reported on originate from is contradicted by the content of the article itself, as well as by his own position as a director of AfriForum and as an employee of the Solidarity Movement.
- He adds that Human’s attempt to claim ignorance and to further divorce himself from AfriForum, as well as filing the complaint in his personal capacity does not rob him of knowledge he has already acquired during his tenure as an AfriForum director.
Paragraph 7
- News24 rejects Human’s claims of reputational harm and embarrassment because:
a. it is difficult to see how disclosure of the remuneration of a qualified senior executive earning a substantial salary could itself cause reputational harm or embarrassment;
b. the remuneration figures came from AfriForum’s own annual financial reports;
c. Human has a complex and wide-ranging operational role across numerous organisations and initiatives, and says that remuneration at this level is not unusual in the private sector for a role of this nature in a large organisation;
d. the complainant only alleges that the incorrect salary figure could cause workplace confusion, conflict or uncertainty; he does not claim that it has happened;
e. Human was not singled out or unfairly portrayed – the article must be considered as a whole;
f. the word “splurge” appears only in the headline and does not refer to the salaries of directors or executives, but rather to AfriForum’s total salary bill over a six-year period;
g. Human does not provide any evidence to support his claims that the reporting was “completely inaccurate, unfair and malicious”; and
h. no other person or organisation has complained about the broader reporting.
Paragraph 8
- Human says that he would have provided documents confirming his employment by the Solidarity Movement and that he received no director’s fee, salary or other compensation from AfriForum in 2023–2024, had News24 given him an opportunity to comment.
- Claassen disputes that those documents disprove any alleged falsities. While those documents support Human’s version, they do not address the core issue – his name appears next to the amounts in AfriForum’s 2024 AFS. He adds that Human attacks the article without referring to the 2024 report itself, which he cannot dispute and has deliberately avoided addressing.
Paragraphs 9 and 10
- News24 maintains that:
a. the reporting is accurate and based on AfriForum’s statutory AFSs;
b. it took reasonable steps to verify the figures, including obtaining confirmation from Buys and confirmation that the remaining figures were accurate;
c. there was no reason to doubt figures contained in AfriForum’s own reports, particularly given Kriel’s confirmation that those reports are accurate; and
d. Human has not produced any evidence that contradicts those figures.
Paragraph 11
- News24 rejects Human’s argument that the “inaccuracies” are particularly serious because the article was presented as an objective, forensic analysis of AfriForum’s financial statements.
- Claassen says that, while the reporting was objective, it was never described as “forensic”. The article was written by an investigative journalist based on documents, facts and responses which contradict Human’s version. Moreover, “he has failed to challenge the evidentiary basis News24 relied on”.
Paragraph 12
- Claassen denies that the article conflates Human’s office as an AfriForum director, his employment by the Solidarity Movement and that it mixes up who pays his remuneration. He submits that the article makes a clear distinction between the two entities and accurately reports his role as a director of AfriForum and employee of the Solidarity Movement (based on AfriForum’s own financial report) records.
- In this regard, he refers to the following statement in the article: “In the same vein, the remuneration of several other directors of AfriForum who work for the broader Solidarity Movement was revealed: Werner Human, the movement’s operational head, earned about R3 million a year, paid for by AfriForum.”
- He concludes, “It is unreasonable and unrealistic of Mr Human to expect News24 to have doubted AfriForum’s own financial statements, particularly not after News24 was assured the statements are accurate and were ‘accepted’ by DSD and SARS.”
Paragraph 13
- Human complains that the article omits elementary facts that AfriForum pays him nothing, that the Solidarity Movement is his employer, and that his actual salary is far below the reported figure, which “prevents the reader from understanding the position in context”.
- News24 argues that:
a. it reported what an AfriForum statutory document recorded about Human’s remuneration, and says there was no objective evidence available at publication proving that AfriForum did not pay him – which means there could have been no omission of a fact;
b. even if Human was paid by the Solidarity Movement rather than by AfriForum, the latter funds the Solidarity Movement Trust, meaning members’ funds ultimately formed part of his remuneration; the article does say that Human was employed by the Solidarity Movement;
c. the article does not omit to state that his actual salary was lower, arguing that this information was not provided to News24 prior to publication and is raised only in the complaint;
d. the article does not make a “central allegation” that Human was singled out as earning the highest salary – it merely reported figures contained in AfriForum’s annual reports, without making an allegation, conclusion, or value judgment about his remuneration; and
e. Human was not singled out, as eight directors were mentioned in relation to remuneration. It says that, if anyone was singled out, it was Buys.
Paragraph 14
- Claassen rejects Human’s conclusion that the article distorts or misrepresents the situation. “Factually, verifiably, the 2024 annual report states that Mr Human was paid these amounts. It is unreasonable to expect that News24 should have doubted this in light of the response from Mr Buys and the assurances that the annual reports were audited, accurate and “accepted” by DSD and SARS.”
Right of Reply
- News24 argues that:
a. it was not required to give Human a right of reply because he was not the subject of critical reporting;
b. it had no reason to doubt AfriForum’s 2024 annual report, particularly because:
i. Buys had confirmed that the remuneration figure attributed to him was accurate;
ii. AfriForum assured it that its reports were accurate and audited; and
iii. AfriForum also indicated that the reports had been accepted by DSD and SARS.
- Claassen contends that, if AfriForum knew the 2024 report contained errors, it should have warned News24 when it specifically asked AfriForum.
- He concludes that further correspondence confirmed that attempts to obtain clarity from AfriForum about directors’ remuneration were futile. It characterises AfriForum as having refused to engage openly and honestly on the issue, and says Human, as an AfriForum director, was aware of this situation but that he did not address it.
Evidence provided
- Claassen directs me to the annexures he sent me to support his arguments. I shall take those into account when necessary.
Rejoinder
The fallacy of the ‘unredacted’ report
- Human says the only “proof” offered by News24 is Annexure N3, which they call the “unredacted” financial statements of AfriForum.
- However, that document is not AfriForum’s approved annual financial report and it was never submitted to the DSD. He submits, “What was submitted to the DSD was Annexure N1, as is confirmed through News24’s answer where they explain at length how they were provided with document ‘N1’ by an intermediary who obtained it directly from the DSD… No official has been presented with the figures in Annexure ‘N3’.”
- He adds that the relevant Act does not require disclosure of salaries or directors’ remuneration.
- Human concludes, “Annexure ‘N3’ is … not a ‘more complete’ report of Annexure ‘N1’. The most accurate way to describe annexure ‘N3’ is a previous draft of Annexure ‘N1’, which was amended and corrected before submission to the DSD by removing the figures. Annexure N1 is a digitally tippexed, final version.”
- In other words, the argument is that News24 treated a recovered earlier draft (N3) as though it were the authoritative, unredacted financial report, whereas the legally submitted and final DSD report was N1.
- He says that, if Annexure N3 was submitted as AfriForum’s annual financial reports to the DSD, he could not have complained. However, “it was not submitted. As News24 itself explains, the figures/previous version they reported on would not have been visible to DSD officials”.
- Human concludes that the crux of the problem is the wrong perception that AfriForum recorded amounts as his remuneration in its financial report submitted to the DSD.
Right of reply
- Human says News24’s contention that it did seek a response through AfriForum about his remuneration as a director, which AfriForum refused to answer, is incorrect and misleading.
- He refers me to question 18 in Annexure N7, where News24 asked why remuneration paid to directors and key personnel was not listed in AfriForum’s annual financial statements from 2020–2024, and asked about the amount of directors’ remuneration.
- He says Kriel did respond, explaining that disclosure of such remuneration was not a reporting requirement of the DSD.
- He also addressed the separate question of directors’ remuneration. In the same annexure, he stated that the Solidarity Movement’s non-profit companies, including AfriForum, did not pay directors’ fees to directors who were employees of institutions within the Movement. He gave himself as an example, saying that although he served on more than ten boards, he received no directors’ fees from those boards.
- Human says this was important because he was himself a non-executive director – and non-executive directors were not receiving directors’ fees from AfriForum.
- He asks why News24 did not ask Kriel about the document that it later found which its journalists interpreted as evidence that non-executive directors had received remuneration.
Verification
- Human rejects News24’s argument that it did take steps to verify its information prior to publication.
- He argues that he was not contacted “before reporting critically about my personal information”, neither were Buys or AfriForum asked about his information.
- He submits that, even if News24 did take reasonable steps to verify, it still offers only an explanation for the error – “it does not undo the factual inaccuracies”.
- Human also contends that it is puzzling that News24 did not simply remove the factual inaccuracies from its reporting after being alerted to them. “It does not detract from the rest of the article, but it embarrasses me greatly.”
- Rather than trying to understand where his misconception came from and how to correct it, Cowan took the stance that AfriForum had to provide different figures before he would even consider rectifying the matter, he continues.
- He concludes that News24 took the “irrational stance” that he had to prove the correct fact before they will remove the incorrect statements. “They do not even offer to update the article by reporting my very pertinent denial of the allegations.”
Employed, paid by AfriForum?
- Human questions News24’s contention that the article accurately describes him as an employee of the Solidarity Movement and a director (not an employee) of AfriForum.
- He argues that News24 improperly isolates a statement (as documented in Paragraph 42), instead of considering the article as a whole. He points to the prominent graphic identifying him under “Salaries of AfriForum directors and key staff”, as well as the reference to AfriForum directors earning R2 million to R3 million a year. In context, he contends, readers would reasonably understand these references to mean that he earned such a salary from AfriForum.
- He further submits that News24 selectively highlights his employment within the broader Solidarity Movement while downplaying the statement that he “earned about R3 million a year, paid for AfriForum.”
- Human argues that, within the context of the article, which is about AfriForum, there can be no doubt that News24, at the very least, intimates or suggests that he worked for AfriForum and therefore earned a salary from that institution.
- He concludes: “There is no factual basis whatsoever to simply state this as fact. This bald statement effectively brands me, and the company secretary who confirmed the correct position as part of my complaint, as liars without any proof. If News24 persists, they will also be calling AfriForum’s independent auditors liars. It is unfathomable that professionals such as registered auditors, a company secretary, and me, being a legal practitioner, would risk our professional reputations by lying to the Ombud or News24 in writing about such an elementary and easily verifiable fact such as whether I received any remuneration from AfriForum.”
- He says the fact that his name appeared in AfriForum’s AFS is a non-consequential, bona fide error. It is non-consequential because no figures were reported under note 22 and no line in the annual financial statements refer to note 22. The full, correct list of directors for the relevant period was identified on page 2 of the annual report, as prescribed.
- He confirms that, after lodging his complaint with the Ombud, he received confirmation of my appointment as deputy CEO of AfriForum, effective from 17 August 2026. “Naturally, I will henceforth be paid as an AfriForum employee. It has no bearing on the factual inaccuracy of what was reported about the period of 2023-2024. It is also hardly controversial that I had a ‘close relationship’ with AfriForum. I was a non-executive director. The arguments take News24’s case no further.”
- Human confirms that the Solidarity Movement Trust is funded by member institutions, inter alia by AfriForum. However, he argues that “there is a world of difference between being paid by AfriForum and being paid by the Solidarity Movement as an employee, even where these entities are related”. He stresses that being funded indirectly by an organisation is not the same thing as being employed or paid by that organisation.
- He argues that News24 is reading too much into Buys’s correspondence (News24 contends that, even if Human’s salary is not directly paid by AfriForum, AfriForum funds the Solidarity Movement Trust, which employs Human – which means that AfriForum members’ funds ultimately contribute to his remuneration).
Director of AfriForum?
- News24 says that Human’s name appears in the 2024 AFS for AfriForum under the heading, “Directors’ remuneration”. Underneath this heading is a further heading: “Executive”.
- Human denies that he was an executive director of AfriForum, while he was a non-executive director. He says News24 knew this, as confirmed by its own response. This “… makes it all the more puzzling why the author did not seek clarity on this very clear discrepancy”.
- A seasoned investigative journalist should understand the distinction between executive and non-executive directors, he opines.
- He adds that the reporter should have realised that the above-mentioned reference was not referenced anywhere in the financial statements and did not explain or support any reported figure. “The note was initially included in error and was in all respects completely meaningless as it did not explain any figure in the financial statements. Nor did it report any figures.”
- Human contends that the error had already been identified before the report was submitted to the DSD. The reducted figures were therefore removed from the draft, but the entire pages could not simply be deleted because they contained other information required for reporting purposes.
Comparative figures
- Human refutes News24’s argument that the 2024 AFS deliberately reports directors’ remuneration for both 2024 and 2023. (News24 says the 2023 AFS did not report directors’ remuneration at all, which explains why the 2024 report includes two years of figures. Accordingly, News24 maintains that Human’s name appearing twice in Note 22 is not a mistake or error, but the result of reporting remuneration for two financial years.)
- He explains that comparative figures are compulsory under applicable reporting standards, which require financial statements to compare the current year with the previous one. Thus, the 2024 figures in Annexure N1 were necessarily compared with 2023 figures.
- He argues that News24’s authors should therefore not have interpreted the inclusion of 2023 comparative figures as evidence of deliberate reporting of two years’ remuneration. “It is, with respect, unacceptable that the authors of the News24 document make far-fetched statements, such as a claim that ‘there was a deliberate effort to report directors’ remuneration for two financial years’, based only on their very obvious lack of subject knowledge.”
- Human concludes that the mere fact that the 2023 AFS in News24’s possession (Annexure N2) did not contain the information “ought to have been another red flag for any reader of the financial statements side-by-side”.
Comment by Buys
- Human says News24’s assertion that comments by Buys provide evidence that its reporting is correct is irrelevant. “The questions do not refer to me at all – either by name or through reference to the R6m/R3m figures.”
- He says it is telling that News24 realised the need to contact Buys for comment, but not him.
- Also: “Neither did the questions … relate to a previous version of annexure N1. News24 referred to ‘the content of the company’s annual financial reports’ – not to the purpose-specific ‘separate financial reports’ submitted to the DSD or any earlier version thereof.
- Moreover, Human says Buys specifically confirmed his own remuneration and did not comment on anyone else’s salaries. The latter explained that his circumstances were unique: unlike other Movement directors, he had assumed his role before the Trust existed, while still heading the Solidarity trade union. AfriForum had a longstanding arrangement with Solidarity to contribute to his salary because he also performed work for other entities. His remuneration was consequently reflected in AfriForum’s financial statements.
- Also, Human submits that Buys did not confirm the accuracy of annexure N3. “Far from it. He was questioned about his compensation amount, which he would immediately have recognized as having been included in AfriForum’s financial statements. It is only News24’s incorrect assumptions that would lead it to believe that Mr Buys knew they were talking about a previous draft of N1. I cannot speak on behalf of Mr Buys and don’t know whether he was aware of the previous draft of N1 or not.”
Logista
- Human says News24 again resorts to speculation based on their own understanding and assumptions. “How can they possibly speculate that the error escape(d) the auditors’”? The annual financial report signed off by Logista did not contain any figures (as they were removed), and there is therefore nothing controversial. It is the ordinary way of doing things. Reports are drafted, revised, and corrected. The board approves a final version. The board-approved final version is presented to the auditors for verification.”
Analysis
The (un)redacted report
- The key to unravelling this matter is to understand what the status of Annexure 1 (AfriForum’s AFS for 2024) and Annexure 3 is:
- Annexure 1 was drafted by AfriForum and was submitted to the DSD with the salaries of the directors blocked out (for whatever reason); and
- Annexure 3 is the same document, with only the blocked amounts having been unblocked. It was not a draft by AfriForum, as Human believes – the figures were unblocked by News24.
- It is not true, Human consistently contends, that the amounts were “removed” before AfriForum sent the document to the DSD. They were not removed; they were blocked out. Removing figures and blocking them out (which can be retrieved) is not the same thing.
- I have no means of knowing whether those figures were corrected, as Human also argues. If they were indeed corrected, it would do nothing to strengthen his case.
- I am cognisant of the evidence that Human submits to prove that he was permanently employed by the Solidarity Movement (and therefore not by AfriForum) and that he has not received any director’s fee, salary, or other compensation from AfriForum, “or has been paid to him in the years 2023-2024, as reported by News24” (as documented under Paragraph 9).
- I have no reason to doubt those testimonies.
- However, News24 based its reportage on an official AfriForum document. Human himself testifies that this document was sent by AfriForum to the DSD. In this document, he is listed as a director or prescribed official who was paid by AfriForum for his services. This alone erodes the basis of his complaint.
- If the information in Annexure 1 is wrong (blocked or unblocked), it is not News24’s fault – then Human should take up the matter with AfriForum and not with News24. He did say the mentioning of his name in the official AFS was a “bona fide error”. The error, it if was one, is not of News24’s making.
- There is only one question on my table: Was News24 justified in reporting that AfriForum had paid Human R3 309 797 in 2023 and R3 015 213 in 2024 (as the unblocked figures indicate)?
- There is no reason whatsoever that News24 should not have reported those figures.
Verification
- I am satisfied that News24’s interaction with Kriel and Buys amounted to sufficient attempts to verify its information.
Right of reply
- News24’s arguments why it was not duty-bound to give Human a right of reply, as documented in Paragraphs 47 – 49, are justified. Why ask for comment when there is an official document, with no reason to doubt its accuracy? And when Kriel has told the reporter that AfriForum consistently complied with legal requirements?
Reputational harm
- As I have found that News24 was justified in its reporting, it follows that I do not believe that the reportage has done unnecessary harm to Human’s reputation.
Finding
- The complaint is dismissed.
Appeals procedure
The Complaints Procedure stipulates that within seven working days of receipt of this decision, either party may apply for leave to appeal to the Chairperson of the SA Press Appeals Panel, Judge Bernard Ngoepe, fully setting out the grounds of appeal. He can be contacted at khanyim@presscouncilsa.org.za
Johan Retief
Acting Press Ombud
29 September 2026
[1] His post can be found at https://x.com/WernerHuman18/status/2089415615303856462.
[2] This is what Kriel wrote to Cowan on 10 June 2026: “20 years of approval by SARS and the Department of Social Development: As a public-benefit organisation and a non-profit company, AfriForum is required by law to report annually to SARS and the Department of Social Development to confirm that AfriForum’s activities adhere to all legal requirements. AfriForum is proud that the organisation consistently complies with this requirement.”
