AmaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism vs Nicqui Galaktiou Inc
BEFORE THE APPEALS PANEL OF THE PRESS COUNCIL OF SOUTH AFRICA
In the matter between
AmaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism Applicant
and
Nicqui Galaktiou Inc 1st Respondent
Nicqui Galaktiou 2nd Respondent
Matter no: 000596/04/2026
___________________________________________________________________
DECISION ON AN APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL
___________________________________________________________________
- This is an application by AmaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism (applicant) for leave to appeal the Ruling by the Acting Press Ombud dated 30 May 2026. The Ruling was on a complaint that had been lodged by Nicqui Galaktiou Inc (first respondent), a firm of attorneys, and Nicqui Galaktiou (second respondent, an attorney). The complaint followed an article by the applicant published on 26 March 2026, with the headline: “Delinquent soccer club boss seeking to revive $1.2bn gas deal with Petrosa”.
- The article was not directed at the respondents as such, but at their client. The complaint was therefore formulated as follows: “Although the publication ostensibly concerns third parties, it contains gratuitous, inaccurate and prejudicial references to the (respondents) that are factually misleading, constitute unfair and unjustified comment and have caused serious reputational harm. The publication contravened Articles 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3 of the Press Code.”
The complaint is a joint one by the two respondents.
- The following are the statements complained about and which are the subject of this application ( the complaint having been partially upheld by the Acting Press Ombud): firstly, that the first respondent was “notorious amongst journalists for their … defence of their clients”. It was said that this was defamatory in contravention of Articles 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3 of the Code. Secondly, the statement that the respondents were “ducking accountability”. The Acting Press Ombud held that the above statements contravened articles 1.1 and 1.3 of the Code and ordered an apology and a retraction. For their part, the applicant had pleaded that the above were a comment, and also say that the sanction is in any case incorrect. The applicant therefore seeks leave to appeal both the finding and the sanction.
- In determining whether or not the applicant has any reasonable prospects of success on appeal, I have considered submissions for and against the application. The appeal is on a narrow issue. The applicant persists that the words complained of constitute protected comments under Clause 7 of the Code. They point out why the Acting Ombud’s Ruling was wrong and go into details why they say so. This is a highly debateable point. I am accordingly of the view that the applicant has reasonable prospects of success on appeal, including on the sanction imposed.
- In the circumstances, leave is hereby granted to appeal the Acting Ombud’s Ruling, on the ground that the impugned words may be found to constitute comments, and that the sanction may be incorrect.
Dated this 1st day of September 2026.
Judge B M Ngoepe, Chair, Appeal Panel
